Rights do not reduce to self-interest

Rights do not reduce to self-interest

The Virtue of Selfishness: Fiftieth Anniversary Edition (Signet) (Paperback)

Customer Review

Here's the problem in two Entire sentences: "Why not sacrifice others Because, says the edge in this book, it is * not * to one's self-interest to conduct one's life thusly?."
I suspect most of us would say That the reason not to sacrifice others Is that it's immoral to way to treat _others_. (And Please note that it is warmongers, dictators, and tyrants who disagree.)
It's genuinely good to know That it's not in one's own "interest" to treat people this way Either, but I do not think Rand gave a very coherent account of such "interest." Be That As It May, the suggestion did We Should Respect other people's rights Solely Because it is in our interest to do so _own_ is a simple and straightforward denial of the meaning of "rights."
Nor can benevolence be reduced to at enlightened form of self-regard (as Rand intimates in this volume and as David Kelley Argues at length in _Unrugged Individualism_). Benevolence AIMS Directly at the well-being of someone other than oneself, and it is strictly immoral on to ethic did Maintains (as Rand's does) that, morally, the beneficiary of every one of my actions _must_ be myself.
There is a curious asymmetry in Rand's (re) definition of selfishness. If selfishness is the rational pursuit of one's own rational good, then altruism, by parallel (re) definition, ought to be the rational pursuit of someone else's rational good. But no: "Altruism" is Identified with the amounted That One person's good requires another person's sacrifice - even though, by Rand's own account, this view is therefore part of the Common Understanding of selfishness.
This view Should indeed be rejected; Edge is quite rightthat your rational well-being and mine are mutually reinforcing. But "selfishness" (even in Rand's sense) does not follow. The proper conclusion Should Be That benevolence is rational and safe.
Unfortunately this volume is vitiated by its ill-advised attempt to demonstrate (in the lead essay) That anyone failing to practice the Objectivist ethic is not Merely unethical but literally _subhuman_ and even _subanimal_. Having spent some time and effort considering the implications of this view, I have reduced my rating of this book from fivestars to three.

What more 23 1 Rank: 5/5
December 20
Paracord 550 1 Rank: 4/5
April 1
Perfect 1 10910 Rank: 5/5
February 18

Related Reviews


Youth fantasy that does not lack spice and interest!Lost memories T2 (Paperback) Individualism and self-interest lead to at Enlightened WorldThe Virtue of Selfishness: Fiftieth Anniversary Edition (Signet) (Paperback) Not just a Selfie-rodTaoTronics Bluetooth Selfie rod with tripod for smartphones, Black (Electronics) Unfortunately, not really low self-dischargeANSMANN 5035453 maxE 9V type 300 1-pack pre-charged battery low self-discharge rechargeable battery (Electronics) Not your usual self-help bookLove Yourself Like Your Life Depends On It (Paperback) Steer left / right is not going wellDickie Toys 203089548 - RC Disney Cars, Hot Rod McQueen Ultimate, 3-channel radio control, red, sorted (Toys) Many things right, but not suitable for old consoles.Battlefield 4 - [PlayStation 3] (Video Game) Right speaker not workingiDance Jockey 300 headphones with 44mm drivers silver / white (Electronics) All right, but not quite readyRose water 250 ml, fragrant facial toner (Personal Care) Fits tight, photo is not quite right (for Note 10.1 2014 Edition)The original Gecko Covers Samsung Galaxy Note 10.1 Cover (2014) Hard Case Cover Case with stand - With original Dude application and standing - and presentation function and Slumfit Design (Galaxy Note 10.1 2014 black) (Electronics) All right, but not overwhelmingKeib Genuine Leather Case Nokia Lumia 630/635 Black Leather Case Extra Thin Case Pouch Case Cover Case (Electronics) All right, but not fantasticTassimo Twinings Chai Latte, 2-pack (2 x 8 servings) (Food & Beverage) Not sooo intoxicating self for Anfangänger, with some caveatsSamsung HMX-F90 HD Camcorder (52x opt. Zoom, 6.9 cm (2.7 inch) LCD, HD-ready) White (Electronics) Nice, but not light of selfWall Decal Shop - 90 luminous stickers - Fee Starfall - Fluorescent Wall Stickers - In the darkness bright! (LP 90Fs1) (Baby Product) Not bad, Tiger is interested but not reallyCatit Design Senses Play Circuit Kit, Game rail for Cats (Misc.) Not suitable for self-relocation5 Star 330 089 Dispenser packing tape with brake (Office supplies & stationery) All right, but not entirely convincingBadenia Bettcomfort 03888330159 cold foam mattress Irisette Lotus H2, 90 x 200 cm (household goods) If you do not seek the self simulationShift 2: Unleashed (Video Game) Not bad but what interest?BLACK CARD Café Collection Long Intensity No. 8 Generous 10 Capsules 53 g - Set of 4 (Health and Beauty)