Send protective case with room for improvement

Currently I am using a neoprene sleeve but after approximately 1 year already pushed to the corner, frayed.

It was important to me
The protective bag is intended to as thin as possible while still "stable" fail (because I want to also insert always in my backpack).

The zipper will not scratch the Notbook.
Especially the edges and corners should be well padded, protected.

... Compared the pockets of Pedea, Plemo and Dicota ...

Bag of Plemo
Neoprentasche
40.5 x 28.5 x 2.5

My 15 '' MacBook Pro fit purely

A double wall construction the handles are inserted laterally.
Very handy, very chic.

In addition, the shell on both side, because where you can "drown" the handles, each a bag which extends over the entire width of the GES. Cover extends.

However, the opening is only possible in the region of the handles, width 13.5 cm
The neoprene can stretch slightly but still.

Just a shame that it about these, really big bags is no side access.
A4 documents can only bring in the main bag itself, the notebook, are inserted.

Everything you put into it, of course bulges outward from ...

Zipper
inside is also through a small bead covered (from both sides).
However, should the Book be slightly thicker, then should no longer suffice the
Here the construction of Dicota works better thought out and thus "safe".

Upholstery
Class on the surface by the double walls.
Unfortunately, however, have the vertices, as well as the peripheral edges no additional protection
Here is just a thin layer of neoprene.

My MacBook is still thin on the inner bead of the seam.
Should the notebook be thicker, which should also fit in securely due to the soft material, then the corner protection should equally be quite mau.

Especially at the corners, my old neoprene case has yet frayed quite fast, pushed through.

Conclusion
Almost a classic neoprene sleeve with retractable handles.
In this double wall can be inserted left and right still plenty of other KrimKram.

Schick and quite handy

Desire
Genial it would be if the outer bag would be accessible (on one side at least) by a larger opening.
In addition, I would like to see a better edge, corner protection.

And if they would still have two small eyes, so I could also optionally carry with a shoulder strap, it would be perfect for my imagination.

For myself I have chosen, however, the bag of PEDEA.

And for those who now do not want to look for the results of my other bags only now, this here in the port.

Case from DICOTA 15.6 ''
Neoprene, black, rounded corners
Outside is still a sewn webbing, which compared with the neoprene certainly scheuerressistenter.
External dimensions 40.5 x 29.5

External trade is so large that comfortably fit in A4 list
In addition, in the trade are three subdivisions, such as Mouse, Power Supply, tel.
I find everything very well done and quite handy.

Zipper
is covered on the inside by an additional, thin neoprene tape
(When the "Book" is, however, thicker, then the zipper could possibly "stop by" the side of the band. However, this will have to be fairly drawn, so I see it as unlikely.)
In addition, the RV made of plastic, so that even if, here and all were in the green zone should

Handle
is well padded (very comfortable, even though they act as almost a bit oversized)

Edge protection
By circulating belt the corners are likely to withstand longer.
As an explicit edge protection but I would clearly like to see more!

If the notebook is a little thicker, so that the inner bead no longer comes into play, it is the "protection" over quickly. And just at the corners of my old neoprene case has yet frayed quite fast, pushed through.

Wishful thinking
Both the edge as well as the corners could be much better padded my opinion.
Unfortunately, that seems to be not yet arrived when the general industry.

And if she would have still left and right, two small eyes, so I could wear them with a shoulder strap, it would, according to my ideas, perfect.

Conclusion
Neoprene sleeve that actually already has the character of a bag.
Not quite as thin and delicate, but it quite versatile bag, and with an elegant touch.

Bag of PEDEA
Outer material is smooth, slightly shiny nylon.
Not quite as elegant, but wiped off and to some degree also water repellent

Upholstery
The areas are already really heavy duty.

The corners are unfortunately how seemingly usual, not specially cushioned mat.
My 15 '' Macbook Pro is also here primarily on the internal Abschlußwulsten.
However, since this bag is somewhat stiffer by the material used, compared to neoprene bags, the corners are a little more stable.
(Whether the material retains the rigidity also in use I can not say at this party)

Pocket
The external, one-sided bag is very large at first glance, but has so its pitfalls
Since mounted approximately 15 cm Zipper (measured from the inside bottom of the bag), you can get a DIN "bend and kink" A4 envelope with insert.
However, the bag itself is high enough that when the envelope is only time indoors, this then also completely fits in. (Halt kinked only ...)

From the length of the zipper can be opened about 33cm.
OK, but would constructively left and right a few cm longer possible. Then the bag would surely be more accessible

And the fact that all the material against neoprene is more tightly you can see the side pocket also not open very far.

All in all ok, but with a slightly different design could certainly use this much more diverse.

Giffe
The handles are also made of the smooth nylon.
What haptic looks a bit cheaper.

Shoulder
But what's awesome for me, is the additional shoulder strap.
This is true only of a simple, 4cm wide adjustable band, but better than nothing.
(And at the two eyelets of the pocket can be as needed to have some other strap mount)

Of all the three tested bags (Plemo, Dicota) it is the only with this feature.

Conclusion
My perfect bag would be a combination of all three.

Because the best here subjectively corner protection as well as the possibility of an additional shoulder belt I now stay with this bag.

Desire
The RV of the outer bag should be mixed up and also about the GES. Be capable of opening width.
Possibly a little remote design the side pocket itself; voluminous make
In the current version all is rather squashed together inside.

In addition, I would like to see a much better edge, corner protection here.