I thought the champagne would be, together with the cuff a nice, elegant gift. (Since you have then the same thing for the toast) Unfortunately, the collar does not fit and sparkling wine gives the word "dry" a new dimension. The second option is a matter of taste, of course, and as the product is labeled as dry, not a reason for a bad review, the non-matching Chiller already. I can indeed use other bottles, but planned was a chilled champagne to give a toast. Conclusion: Good, but not overwhelmingly good