I discovered Manhattan-Kabul by pure luck. This song upset me. I can not listen without saying that Renaud has put his finger on what was necessary to insist in 2001 as now: Victims of violence should not be judged by the place of their death. These small Puerto Ricans, these little Ecuadorians, my compatriots, who have made the WTC pulverizer can not be insulted and forgotten only because they had the bad idea to choose New York to try to have a better life. Similarly Afgans that they had the right to live, even as they were Afgans murdered people. Thank you, Mr. Renaud to have had the sensitivity to see beyond the ideologies to create a wonder of sincerity and intelligence.