"There's not that apple ... there also turnip!"

Unlike the Asterix universe which made a field day, Morris had always forbidden to René Goscinny to any pun or pun in Lucky Luke. I think Maurice de Bevere would have hated this album.

The drawings of Achdé are very successful, very faithful to the original design.

It can not be said of the scenario: almost fully transpose the world of "Tontons Flingueurs" in the world of Lucky Luke is absolutely not work, it is very laborious and clumsy!

Jacques and Laurent Gerra Pessis still do not understand the world of comics and this catchy album, which no doubt will be a commercial success, alas, will not bring anything to the legend of the lone cowboy.