Among the ingredients can really say anything negative. I'm really a big fan of the brand and still have a rouge and lipstick, which I find simply fantastic! The mascara is unfortunately less my thing. The brush separates the lashes not as I would like. The consistency is rather thick so quickly form clumps on my lashes. I think I have to stay more in the silicone / Plastikbürstchen. These to me the effect like better.