Translation takes too many liberties with the original

Translation takes too many liberties with the original

Beowulf (Norton Critical Editions) (Paperback)

Customer Review

I would strongly recommend to stay away from Heany's Beowulf translation. I understand some Old English, unfortunately not well enough to fluently read the original. But I understand enough to realize just how many liberties Seamus Heany Took with the original. He Actually managed to lose me with the first word, Which is something of an achievement. He starts his translation with 'So.' The original has the word 'Listen!', Which Evokes how this story which originally learned by heart and told to An Audience That was called upon to be quiet and pay attention to the speaker. (These very old text were originally spoken and only later written down.) Heany goes on like that, with a style That is far too removed from the tone and meaning of the original. Some readers enjoy his style, so if you just like his writing and do not mind That it's far removed from the original, that's okay. But if you want to get to know the original 'Beowulf' then this translation is not for you.

Slept well! Rank: 5/5
November 27
Power smartphones even smarter Rank: 5/5
October 15
Partafaite Rank: 5/5
January 6
ATTENTION! surprises! Rank: 1/5
July 13

Related Reviews


Ingenious idea, but can not compete with the originalSchmidt Spiele 49257 - Qwirkle Cubes (Toys) Very many - too many - restrictions of the Lexus RX 400hZemex V3 USB iPod iPad iPhone Aux MP3 adapter Toyota Lexus Celica Corolla Land Cruiser MR2 Carmy Prius RAV 4 Yaris Auris Amazon LS400 LS430 RX 300 SC 430 (Electronics) has probably nothing to do with the originalZatar spice preparation, 35g (Misc.) No difference with the original 3Hama Li-Ion Battery "DP 026" for Olympus C-5060/7070/8080, E series (identical to Olympus BLM-1) (Accessories) a difference with the original battery detectedLookit - brand battery - latest generation 100% - 1000mAh - Compatible for Canon PowerShot SX600 HS, Canon PowerShot S200, Canon PowerShot SX700, Canon PowerShot D30, Canon PowerShot SX510 HS, PowerShot SX170 IS, PowerShot S120, Canon Ixus 300, Canon Ixus 310 ( Electronics) no comparison with the original, unfortunately ...Need for Speed: Most Wanted - Limited Edition - [PC] (computer game) Product compliant with the originalSITRAM - HANDLE COVER SITRAFORZA for pressure cookers / casseroles minutes SITRAM (Kitchen) Contact the charger / battery is random. (With the original battery and with others from other manufacturers)Charger + AHDBT-301 Batteries GoPro Hero3 Black, White & Silver Edition (Sport) Fully compliant with the originaloriginal battery for Wiko Cink Slim wiko (Electronics) No difference with the original (non-price), is recognized by EOS 6D, RecommendationBundle Star * BAXXTAR PRO-ENERGY quality battery for Canon LP-E6 with Chip Info - Intelligent battery system - "next generation" for Canon EOS 70D 60D 60Da 7D Mark II 6D 5D Mark II III (Electronics) in perfect harmony with the original Elpida RAM (2x4GB) modules in my 27 "iMacCrucial CT2C8G3S160BMCEU memory 16GB (1600MHz, CL11, 2x 8GB) DDR3 RAM kit (accessory) Flip Cover not comparable with the original qualityitronik® Flip Cover Protective display cover for Samsung Galaxy SIV S4 I9195 Mini Black (Wireless Phone Accessory) Unfortunately, the power supply does not fit with the original Apple CasesPrima Case - Car Charger for Apple iPhone 4, 4S, 3, 3G, 3GS / iPod Touch / iPad 1, 2 & 3 (Electronics) No difference with the original 2[Apple MFi zertfiziert] Syncwire Lightning to USB cable - Lifetime Warranty -. 3.3 ft / 1m for iPhone 5S 5C 6 Plus 5, iPad Air 2, 3 Mini, iPod 5th generation and iPod nano 7th generation - White (Personal Computers) Tested and compared with the original battery.Samsung Li-ion Battery 1030 mAh for L100 / 110/200/210 / 310W, WB500, IT100, PL50 / 60/65, ES55 (Accessories) Fully compatible with the originalBundle Star Premium Battery for Sony NP-FM500H (1600mAh !!) with Info Chip (latest generation 100% compatible!) (Electronics) No difference with the original battery detectedPELTEC @ Premium Notebook Laptop Battery HP Compaq 6720s 6730s 6735s 6820s 615 550 610 4400mAh (Electronics) Works well with the original Canon 18 - 55 mmTeleconverter 2.2x Oting for CANON EOS 1200D 1100D 1000D 700D 650D 600D 550D 500D 450D 400D 350D 300D 100D 10D 20D 30D 40D 50D 60D 1D 5D 6D 7D (Electronics) Fully compliant with the original cables[Apple] RAVPower® Lightning to USB Cable [MFI certified data synchronization, load] for iPhone 6/6 Plus / 5 / 5C / 5S, iPad Air, iPad mini, iPod nano 7th generation, iPod Touch 5th generation - White - 3.3 ft / 1 m cable (Electronics)