A controller was for me, the other for a mate. When unpacking, I noticed with a controller that seemingly flies around a small part in this. It rattles when you shake. Could be a small screw. The LT (Left, lower lever) is pressing conspicuously loud (creaks a bit) and perhaps missing since the flying screw, so my guess. When Vibrate not hear this from flying particles, fortunately. To return my buddy so far was not ready, the controller is so dear to his heart that he can no longer 1 week without. Second Controller: He was unpacking High as expected when ordering and had no flaws or other abnormalities. Play after the first intense (on PC; NFS Shift 2) I noticed that the left joystick squeaks. But since I'm playing with headset or loud speakers, I do not hear that often. The squeak is heard only when you move it quickly. It's not a disgusting or annoying squeal loud. But it is now times there and you notice it during the game if one respects it.