Furthermore, the filter is not quite as slim, white I would have expected. I got it with the Canon 24mm 2.8 IS tasted the slightly vignetting even at f8, but the filter caused here visible vignetting. I wonder why we designed slim filter that does not serve its purpose at 24mm. For larger focal lengths they are then superfluous. The vignette is not soo much, you get over it might, but then to extol as a product as Vignettierungsfrein is questionable. Perhaps the problem is the lens that used in 24mm only a 58mm thread, I can not judge.
Maybe you could be here to save the upper filter thread, even if you can slip on dan no other filters.
I still have a polarizing filter in Slim, causing no vignetting, so I put the blame on this filter.