Why only this retrogression?

Why only this retrogression?

Wish You Were Here-Ltd.Edition (Audio CD)

Customer Review

I also own all editions of this unique work of art and actually thought that I arrived at the Remaster version from 2011 onwards my goal. When I found out now that this eimalige album and then as a multichannel SACD comes out, so of course I immediately slammed shut. When the SACD was there, they came in immediately and I was immersed in the world of Wish You Were Here. As for the mixing of the individual instruments, one has simply done right everything, say everything is wonderful spread around the listener, the effects surround a and play with the senses, but in terms of the sound, came the great disillusionment. I compared the SACD with the Remaster version of 2011 at the stereo. Why there must be such a deterioration here? The SACD sounds partly serh muffled, the bass is unclean and the cristal clear playback at mid and high frequencies, which can still be heard on the 2011 version, is here entirely missing.
I have the SACD of course brought me only because of the multi-channel sound, because I was already very satisfied with the 2011 version yes. As I have then listened to the SACD Stereo times in times in multi-channel, so I unfortunately had to find that the same tonal deficits is heard while multi-channel operation. Here also all sounds somewhat dull and many details which are out listen perfectly to the 2011 version, are barely perceptible here. The only thing that one can hit a little higher, the heart, of course, is the multi-channel sound, which leaves a over the sonic shortcomings overlooked something, but unfortunately I can only rate as follows:
Sound Stereo SACD: 2 stars (significantly worse than the 2011 Vesion)
Multichannel sound: 3-4 Stars (although good mixing of the individual instruments, the poor sound gets stuck)

Conclusion: 3 stars

Wish for the future: At least the same sound quality as on the 2011 remastered version as multichannel.

Addendum on 15:03:12:
After several auditioning must admit that the Mehrkanalabmischung has failed significantly better than the Zweikanalabmischung. Since it fetches almost only because of Mehrkanalabmischung, I have set high evaluation from three to four stars. While it still lacks some details compared to the 2011 version, but the division is so grandiose succeeded that the album is a strong buy recommendation!

great color 3 1 Rank: 5/5
May 11
HBCI reader Appel IMac Rank: 3/5
November 6
fun and addictive! 1 Rank: 4/5
November 26
It is installed and that's it. Rank: 5/5
January 29
loved May 1 Rank: 5/5
September 21

Related Reviews


Why only this limited range?Rayman Origins (Original Game Soundtrack) [Billy Martin Selection] (MP3 Download) Why only this Gymkhana ????Dirt 3 (video game) Very important accessory for meaningful villas Duplo game, but why is this plate so thin?Lego Duplo 2304 - Big building board, green (toy) Why only one choice on vinyl?Live in New York [Vinyl] (Vinyl) Why only half?HP 57 Photo Starter Pack - 60 sheets / 10 x 15 cm plus tab (Office supplies & stationery) Why only the few songs?Step Up 3D (Audio CD) Only this!Braun Multiquick 5 Citrus Juicer juicer MP22 (household goods) Why only one star? Product quality, pose ...NILLKIN H + Lumia 1520 - Tempered Glass Screen Protector for Nokia Lumia 1520 - scratchproof and ULTRA RESISTANT - INDEX 9H Hardness (Electronics) Super, you need eigendlich only this book.Essential Grammar in Use: Edition with Answers (Paperback) Only this - no one elseLeitz 50086095 Punch, 2.5 mm, with stop rail, blister, black (Office supplies & stationery) Why only 4 stars?Varta Blue C22 52 Ah Car Battery (Miscellaneous) The album is great - only this title ....Till I Die [Explicit] (MP3 Download) Cubot One or why only buy expensive mobile phone.Cubot One 4.7 "quad-core 1.2GHz CPU 3G Smartphone Dual SIM mobile phone Android 4.2.1 White (Electronics) Why only one ring cable !!!Quality i-TTL flash cable 3,6m for Nikon D7100, D7000, D5300, D5200, D5100, D5000, D3200, D3100, D3000, D800, D700, D610, D600, D300, D300, D200, D100, D90, D80, D70 D60, D50, D40, D3 series, D2 series, D1 series, N90s, F5, F6, F100, F90, F90X - similar to SC-28 / SC-29 (electronic) only "this" hereBosch Wiper Blade Aerotwin set AM467S - Length: 650/475 (Automotive) Quality top, only this is not a "Fuchsia" ...White & Fuchsia TPU Silicone Case Cover Skin Case for Samsung I9100 Galaxy S2 (2 pieces) (Electronics) Why only on 5?The Elf Adventure - Advent and Interactive story (App) From now on only this litter!Cat's Best Öko Plus cat litter 28441, 40 liters (Misc.) 5 star worthy, then why only 1?Bloons TD 5 (app)