Both not fit impeccably. Although the phone is not thrown out, the shell is yet bulky and could be seen in each case (albeit at different points) shine through the silver lining of the smartphone that is to be actually covered.
In addition, the "Girl Kissing Skull" already a top layer of the material began after a day to peel off.
Oh, I can not recommend it, even for the price - including shipping is not worthwhile for the quality that you get.