Perfectly clear - this CD will split the fan base. For rock and less melodious than in the past for some, as strong and as rocking at their concerts for the other. As is so often the truth lies in the middle - 5 euros into phrases pig ;-) It's really for all tastes. The CD starts rocking, but goes into the second half back to the Pop (eg Friends) above. Of course, the Scots forget even when the rock songs your ability a catchy melody do not (for example "Something Anything"). During the last two CD's stayed away the surprises and much looked very smooth, there is the "Ode to J Smith" quite corners, edges and also surprises (the second half of "J. Smith"). For me, the CD starts strong, hangs in the middle a little bit towards the end and will again very good, especially with the strong final point "Before you were young."