A great cycle, but less homogeneous than they say

A great cycle, but less homogeneous than they say

Schumann: The 4 Symphonies - Openings - Scherzo & Finale (CD)

Customer Review

The quality of the Schumann cycle is well known: the famous Dresden Staatskapelle it sounds like she's magnificent orchestra. Wolfgang Sawallisch is excellent in the Second Symphony and the rarest Overture, Scherzo and Finale (you can listen and listen without tiring the Scherzo, execution model removed and elegant). Stereo wide and flattering, which ages well.

In odd-numbered symphonies, however, Sawallisch is a more competent leader than exciting and predictably, the comfort of its direction does not really give an exhilarating sense of this music. It must be said in his defense that these symphonies are formidable and that many leaders even among the best teeth are broken it (the cycle of Szell's not really what we would have expected). In their integrals, Leonard Bernstein more fire in the First (with New York at CBS / Sony) and Rafael Kubelik makes better with the Bavarian Radio climates Rhenish. This package can be complemented with isolated interpretations more intoxicating symphonies one, three and probably four (Sawallisch because it is good, but the work has a raised discography, including Wilhelm Furtwängler and Hermann Abendroth). There remains the case of the sublime Second, where are many exciting alternatives if we look a little (you can hear Toscanini, Fritz Reiner, Mitropoulos, Bruno Maderna, and others).

great shirt for our drummer Rank: 5/5
August 30
compliant but Rank: 3/5
March 21
but good 53 Rank: 3/5
February 24
A whole saga in one book! Rank: 4/5
August 17

Related Reviews


very nice but less protective than the gelOrig Nokia CC-3041-C wireless charger Case for Lumia 820 Blue (Accessory) Good but less complete than othersLonely Planet Costa Rica (Paperback) nice but less nice than the pictureEJY Women sexy dresses ladies transparent white floral lace embroidery boho hippie pop hook mini party dress (clothing) Not bad, but less powerful than the original batteryABC Products® Replacement Fuji / Fujifilm NP-50 / NP50 / NP-50A / NP50A Li-ion / Battery to select Finepix Digital Camera (model shown below) (Electronics) Like all beautiful, but less comfortable than the timeless "Chuck Taylor".Converse Star Player Ev Leath Mid, sneakers Unisex Fashion (Clothing) Great ring, but slightly smaller than on the imageKonov jewelry men-s ring, women's ring, stainless steel, Bible prayer cross, silver - Gr. 59 (Jewelry) backup batteries, but less reliable than the original.ChiliPower 1850mAh Battery LP-E6 (with Infochip) for Canon EOS 6D, EOS 7D, EOS 60D, EOS 60Da, EOS 70D, Canon EOS 5D Mark II, EOS 5D Mark III (Electronics) good but less powerful than the old modelLogitech Z150 PC speakers 3W Black (Personal Computers) Cute but less emotional than Volume 1Chi - A Cat Vol.2 (Paperback) Good but less flexible than leatherClarks Smart Deva, woman Sandals (Shoes) great light, but no better than cheap battery lightBusch & Müller lighting Dynamo diode rear light Toplight Line plus LED, black (equipment) Super Chic design but less power than the Huawei Ascend G 615!Huawei Ascend P6 smartphone (11.9 cm (4.7 inches) touch screen, 8 megapixels, 8GB memory, Android 4.2) (Electronics) Looks very cute, great colors but unfortunately larger than 135cm!Fine beaver Christmas Bedding 135x200 cm Elche made in Germany branded goods from Ido homewear Good but less universal than hardWago WAG2273 / 203BL15 Pack 15 2273 15 x 3 terminal inputs (Tools & Accessories) Compatible but less powerful than the original batery.Battery for Navibot SR8845, SR8855, SR8848, SR8895, SR8990 (Electronics) Safety shoes comfortable but less durable than before.Caterpillar Holton St Sb, Human Safety Shoes (Shoes) Beau modem but less effective than my old which cost only € 30EX6200-100PES Repeater Netgear WiFi AC1200 Dual band 5 Gigabit Ethernet ports (Accessory) Satisfactory but less efficient than older modelsBosch MSM 6150 white / gray Hand Blender (Accessory) Good but less universal than sugarsWago WAG51196507-15 / 222413 Bag of 15 terminals 3 x 2,5 mm² (Tools & Accessories)