Biography minor, uninteresting

On the form first, chaptering is questionable, both chronologically and thematically, when it would have been more appropriate to choose one or the other, to avoid duplication (many). Ms. Trédez being a journalist with the magazine "Elle", one can not wonder that the style is ... "Ellien" in a tone of complicity girly quick to bang his head against the walls, plenty of small sterile remarks, which overwhelm more than they make us smile. As the unexpected interview ... Carla Bruni-Sarkozy, who concluded by saying "From New York to the Elysee, Amy Winehouse is unanimous." No comment.

On the merits, Amy Winehouse seems reduced to a "rebellious icon," as the title of the book. It tells how, from an early age, she was flirting with the insolence with his girlfriend Juliette. They say his amorous hysteria, his addictions, his lack of affection ... As if Amy Winehouse had a face, as if it were reducible to its excesses, ultimately. It is a mistake, to write a biography by hiding a whole side of the story. In sum, the research work, too light will make this biography more a marketing product designed to speak to feminist generation 2000 a reference book ...