Adrien Bosc is a brilliant young writer with impeccable style when he holds forth about chance, fate or coincidence. His basic idea is sound. In fact remains that you it this plane crash which prematurely took the boxing star, Marcel Cerdan and the prodigy violinist Ginette Neveu? Try to find the other 37 passengers and anonymous tracking what motivated their departure that day, on that plane there to find "the infinite competition causes that determines the most unlikely result" could have led to an exciting novel. But now, the relationship between Spanish and French investigators, the conclusions of Air France, cuts presses set out warrants that the crash, the testimonies of the aid, the transcript of a TV literary quotations and the many programs ... In short one immersed in a report which is not really exciting. The novel is relatively short, 190 pages, it is frustrated about the lives of anonymous passengers. And when you find yourself in a 14-page biography, well flat style of a famous unknown, associate of Walt Disney, you start to get bored. As for the demonstration, which aims to track down the irony of fate or implacable hand of "objective chance" it does not really convinced me!