I do not know what are the other recessions here ... This case has neither a lid through which the home button is covered up a magnetic closure which is too light on. No matter. I find this case super. Wertig stable and looks great. Negative is simply that it is a bit "heavy". But this is to cope with since the iPhone seems to be very well protected. However, but for me an absolute no-go, that the dumb-rocker is virtually impossible to achieve. Even my friend had problems with long fingernails to reach him. That is why, unfortunately, the shell goes back also. The slightly wider cut or relocated rocker outward and the case would be perfect.