Convinced not in long-term test

Convinced not in long-term test

Logitech G19 Gaming Keyboard USB corded (German keyboard layout, QWERTY) (Personal Computers)

Customer Review

I bought the Logitech G19 in December 2011 and now it's July 2012. So I had about six months time to test this keyboard through its paces.

In the first impression is good keyboard. The design fits the specially coated keys feel great, different lighting options are great and the twelve macro keys, which still per profile are also triple-assignable, leave nothing to be desired.

An endurance test performed then but reveal some weaknesses. Probably the most serious are that the mini-monitor in principle is useless and that the keys are not mechanical, but Rubber dome keys.

On paper, the monitor is enormously useful. Statistics could be displayed, presented the current Teamspeack Channel, a mini map of the current game could be shown here ... theoretically everything super. But the truth is that the use of this monitor dependent hundred percent whether the developers of the program that you just used, such an additional function for the G19-Monitor. Since the G19 is but seemingly not so widespread, there are very very few applications that can make use of the additional monitor. Most annoying is definitely that there is no app for TeamSpeak 3, what I really wanted to use primarily the monitor.
The only program that is gaining real added value by being Fraps. Here, the current frame rate, a frame rate histogram and a recording icon will (of course, only when recording) is displayed. This is great and shows what potential is actually wasted here by the fact that this monitor is just as bad supported.
I use the monitor at the moment really only to display the time and had the alarm clock next to my screen well done alone.
In addition, the monitor is far too expansive designed for the screen size that he has, and so can make it difficult to transport. The power supply, which provides the Monitor and the USB2 Hub with power, by the way is not very handy.

Now another problem, which is really significant. After half a year of continuous use demonstrates the weakness of cheap rubber dome keys: in several games, especially first person shooters, keys are (especially WASD) also pressed times over a long period. But now I had lately more often the problem is that the W key is no longer registered with the stop after some time. That is, for example, in an online shooter like Battlefield 3, that the character of a full Sprint simply stops, the helicopter suddenly is no more thrust and simply falls out of the sky or that the jet is no longer accelerating. All that means 90% of the virtual death and that is absolutely unacceptable for a so-called gaming keyboard! In my opinion, that can only have two causes: either the driver software (I'm on Win7 64) is wrong, or it is really up to the Rubber dome keys, which after half a year already have such defects.
The keystroke does not feel accurate, which is another shortcoming.

In my opinion the G19 is much, much too expensive for what it does and not suitable in the long run to excessive gambling. I have now ordered as a contrast to this keyboard, the SteelSeries gaming keyboard 6Gv2 German. This has Cherry MX Black mechanical keys (supposedly the best for gaming) and gives me so hopefully the precise keystroke, I miss at the G19. It also provides the opportunity to be connected to PS / 2, which the G19 has also not (PS / 2 is better for keyboards as USB because this interface virtually all keys on the keyboard can be pressed and detected simultaneously, USB has here a maximum of six simultaneous keystrokes with software tricks up to 20). The only real advantage of G19 against such a keyboard I see in the macro keys that lacks the 6Gv2. But since I mostly play first-person shooter, I have the macro keys anyway almost not needed.

Nothing to complain about 8 2 Rank: 5/5
August 21
Perfect 1561 Rank: 5/5
January 29
Bad !!! 22 1 Rank: 2/5
March 14
it is not made for such WIKO Rank: 1/5
February 25
happy January 34 Rank: 4/5
March 23

Related Reviews


Good work lamp, but not yet long-term testsBlack Professional High Power LED Torch with Dimmer & Zoom - in rechargeable battery, power cord - shockproof and waterproof - 3 different functions including crossfading. Not passed long-term testKrups XL 2000 milk frother (household goods) Long-Term TestSoehnle 61350 PWD Silver Sense Digital Bathroom Scale (Personal Care) Mounting properly, makes a good impression so far. Long-term test is missing.2 x DISAGU Armored Screen Protector for LG L Bello breakage protector (Wireless Phone Accessory) In long-term test with mixed feelingsBraun Gillette Venus Naked Skin IPL Intense Pulsed Light Hair Removal (Personal Care) Long-term test with flying colors!Durable 574,858 wrist rest Mouse pad with gel wrist pad Ergotop Mouse pad Ergotop with gel, textile, 230x260x26 mm, anthracite (Office supplies & stationery) Attachment completely simple and bubble-free - long-term test is still pending3 x atFoliX protector Panasonic Lumix DMC-LX7 Screen Protector - FX antireflective glare-free (electronic) Long-Term Test: Castle has high security - are key but crap!ABUS Folding Lock Bordo Granit X-Plus, 85 cm, 6500/85 (equipment) Results in long-term tests remain inClarisonic Mia 2 Sonic Skin Cleansing System - White (Personal Care) Gillette in long-term testGillette MACH3 Sensitive Power Razor battery-powered (Personal Care) First 5 Top. Long-term test is made.Safetec SA 13 Gr. M Safetec Motorradabdeckplane (Automotive) Perfect! The long-term test will show how much quality is in these matsSkoda Octavia III 3 from Bj.2013 - floor mats Set rubber, black Long-Term Test: For the price okay, but no particular qualityWickey sandbox King Kong 190x190 Initially, funny, but not a long-term fun12 bending pencils 32 cm - bending pencil (Toys) Long-Term Test Dermaroller 1.5mm ** UPDATE 04/27/15 - 5. Treatment **1:50 mm SODACODA Dermaroller Needling Skin Roller 540 microneedles for for deep acne scars, surgical scars, chickenpox scars, pimple scars, extensive hair loss, cellulite, slight stretch marks, removes pigmentation - Titanium microneedle needle quality product! (Personal Care) (Relative) Quiet power supply with very many cables and good efficiency (no long-term test)Super Flower SF450P-14XE 80+ Gold PC power supply ATX 2.92 450 Watt (Accessories) Long-Term Test FailedSigel VZ131 Business Card Case, silver, black, aluminum / leather look, for up to 20 cards (max. 90x58 mm) (Office supplies & stationery) Thrilled! + Long-term testSebson G4 LED lamp 3W - cf. 20W bulb - 200 lumens - G4 LED warm white - LED lamps 110 ° - 12V (household goods)