A bit skeptical when I saw the reviews, I still launched this purchase because it was the only solution for us (on the wall of the shower). Indeed, this article is plastic not metal but the appearance is rather successful. So visual question, I can not find much to complain about. For holding, we followed the instructions as to stick the small transparent sticker before setting the hook. As mentioned above, we have placed on the wall of the shower, outside of the tray. For the moment, it holds well. He did not pick up. We have hung towels. No complaints. Only one thing to say: as long as it lasts but for now, we are satisfied with this purchase.