Not recommended - Macbook Pro (mid 2007).

Not recommended - Macbook Pro (mid 2007).

Seagate Momentus XT ST95005620AS Internal Hard Drive 500GB (6.3 cm (2.5 inches), 7200RPM, 32MB cache, SATA) (Accessories)

Customer Review

After the built-up of Apple Toshiba drive after more than 5 years of service was slow and full support, had to be a new record. Within my research for a new plate, I came across this Seagate Momentus XT and have been buying even daring. The price is a bit higher as in other 500 GB hard drives, but the hoped-for faster access times were worth it to me at the end.

When the plate arrived, I put these and partitioned first into a hard drive enclosure. Using the disk utility (later also with CarbonCopyCloner) the entire contents of my old drive was pulled to the Momentus XT, ie 1: 1 mirrored. Then installed the new drive in my Macbook and started.

First disappointment: Start time -> First boot (and all subsequent boots) of Macbooks lasted about as long as the old disk (about 1 min 50 sec). Since the restart in the Apple world very rarely carried out, I did not let myself be swayed this way.
The first few minutes in my first Mountain Lion ran smoothly. The apps were launched much more quickly, and the Switch among themselves ran smoothly. But my joy did not last long. At idle, the hard drive has eventually hung up, the result was the pretty beach ball (which in Windows is the hourglass) and continuous freezer. It only helped the restart, which brought about the second problem. At start-up the two symbols "Hold prohibited sign" and "folder with an exclamation point" came one after the other in quick succession. Apparently there was problems with this disk as the startup disk.
I crossed first few forums and led folgedes by:

- Hard disk, this time with mirrored CarbonCopyCloner
- PRRAM reset (CMD + ALT + P + R)
- Firmware the Momentus XT to the SD28 update (here you have to download the firmware as .iso, burn them to CD and can boot the Macbook from the CD).
Checked start volume in the Settings -

The reboot worked from this time now .... but the hard drive continues to react with constant (on) hangers, was now noticeably slower than at the beginning, everything seemed very sluggish. I read the plate about rödeln an hour without success. I have not got this board up and running and had sometime the snout fully. I give the panel an extra point since I first realized what "can" afford this plate.

Have these now returned and waiting today to WD7500BPKT Scorpio Black!

good and cheap 97 Rank: 5/5
April 7
Software provided by WD Rank: 2/5
December 18
Used 5 times and hs Rank: 1/5
November 15
meli melo tomes Rank: 2/5
March 26
The product trials Rank: 5/5
September 30

Related Reviews


6GB in my macbook pro mid 2007!4GB DDR2 SODIMM Komputerbay (200 pin) 667Mhz PC2-5400 / PC2-5300 CL 5.0 NON-ECC Unbuffered 1.8v memory DDR2-667 Module (Accessory) Perfect Upgrade for MacBook Pro (Mid 2009)Samsung 8GB Dual Channel Kit (2x 4GB, 204 pin, DDR3-1066, PC3-8500 SO-DIMM) (Electronics) Perfect for the MacBook Pro (Mid 2009)Pico Finish Phillips Schraubendreher.261 PF PH 00x40 (tool) Perfect for MacBook Pro Mid 2012Samsung 8GB Dual Channel Kit 2 x 4 GB DDR3-1600 204 pin SO-DIMM (1600Mhz, PC3-12800S, CL11) (Personal Computers) Everything top! (Macbook Pro Mid '2010)8GB Dual Channel Kit CSX original 2 x 4 GB DDR3-1066 200 pin (1066, PC3-8500, CL7, 204 pin) SO-DIMM for DDR3 notebooks (electronic) Experience when upgrading a 13 "MacBook Pro (Mid 2010)Samsung MZ-7TE500BW Series 840 EVO Basic internal SSD hard drive (6.3 cm (2.5 inches) (500GB, 512MB cache, SATA III) metallic silver (Personal Computers) Apple Certified storage for MacBook Pro mid 2012Corsair Apple certified 16GB (2x8GB) DDR3 1600 MHz (PC3 12800) Laptop Memory (CMSA16GX3M2A1600C11) (Personal Computers) Impeccable with MacBook Pro Mid 2012Kingston 8GB DDR3 1600MHz Non-ECC CL11 SODIMM (Personal Computers) Ram Update MacBook Pro Mid 2012Kingston KVR16S11K2 / 16 memory 16GB (1600MHz, PC3-12800, CL11, 2x 8GB) DDR3 SO-DIMM (Personal Computers) Works perfectly with a Macbook Pro Mid 2010 15 "Crucial MX200 SSD Flash Internal 2.5 "500GB SATA III - CT500MX200SSD1 (Personal Computers) Runs in the Macbook Pro Mid 2010 13 "Mushkin PC3-8500 RAM 16GB Essentials (1066 MHz 204-pin, 2x 8GB) SO-DIMM DDR3 RAM (Accessories) MacBook Pro mid 2010 with an older external hard driveInLine FireWire cable, 6-pin / 9-pin male / male, 1m (accessory) MacBook Pro Mid 2009Samsung 840 Pro Series internal SSD hard drive 256GB (6.4 cm (2.5 inch), 512MB cache, SATA III) anthracite (Personal Computers) An excellent SSD for my MacBook Pro mid 2010MX100 SSD Flash Drive Crucial Internal 2.5 "256GB SATA (Personal Computers) How to revive an old Macbook Pro Mid 2009 ...Crucial M550 SSD internal CT256M550SSD1 Flash Drive 2.5 "256GB SATA III (Personal Computers) Excellent MacBook Pro mid 2009 and 27-inch Asus1.8m Apple Mini Display Port to HDMI Converter with NEET®. (Video + Audio unibody MacBook -Pro-Air + iMac PCs with Mini Display Port etc ...) Compatible with the new THUNDERBOLT Port **** **** WITH AUDIO (Electronics) Violent disappointment in the MacBook Pro (Mid 2009)Western Digital WD7500BPVT Blue 750GB internal hard drive (6.4 cm (2.5 inches), 5400rpm, 12 ms, 8MB Cache) (Personal Computers) Very reasonable and good grabber for MacBook Pro Mid. 2012LogiLink VG0011 USB Audio and Video Grabber with Snapshot for Mac and PC (option) Runs perfect in MacBook Pro Mid 2012Hynix 16GB Dual Channel Kit 2 x 8 GB 204 pin DDR3-1600 SO-DIMM (1600Mhz, PC3-12800, CL11, 1.35V, for Apple and notebook) (Personal Computers)