Good sounding sham at good price!

Good sounding sham at good price!

Bose ® Companion ® 2 Series III Multimedia Speaker System (Electronics)

Customer Review

For a small room (about 12sqm) in a student I was looking for a not too expensive, but good sounding, active stereo speaker system (without a subwoofer) for enjoyable listening. Although I am a self-proclaimed engineer, but studio monitors to make a studio, I do not need.

After a long research on the net I ordered short hand two systems:
- The Bose Companion 2 Series III for 88, - Euro
- The Samson Media ONE 5a for 149, - Euro

Perhaps an unfair comparison, even more so when one considers the performance values ​​and speaker sizes.
But Bose writes many yes - despite sham - for the music and movie enjoyment miraculous powers to.

I want to write here not long comparative tests, but go directly to my personal impressions.
In exchange I have with both systems different music sample belongs: BigBand, modern classical, pop, musicals, rock to techno.

Make The Bose for their size already really what ago.
You have a beautiful, warm bass and let that one can sink into the music.
Without comparison, I would have probably rated 5 stars.
The sticking point: The middle tone range is nahzu not existend.
The Samson system is much more linear frequency response.
Comparing the systems will only become clear how much the Bose system easily swallowed.

With soft music shows the following to:
Bose: Stressed Bass, little centers, beautiful and clear treble.
Sounds good, but not every music stands on duration of said Bass.
In particular voices and vocal work (in comparison!) Narrow and high.
Some instrument, like a discreet electric guitar going even under times.
Samson: Balanced, beautiful, clear sound for dipping.
Everything is present over the entire tape, from bass to treble, nothing stands out too strongly, rattles or disruptive.
One can say that Samson pair has everything the Bose pair has also, but adds some of what the Bose speakers missing.

If one makes a loud also shows quickly that the Bose-pair but has considerably less Leistungsreservern.

My recommendation clearly: Samson Media ONE 5a.
Is it worth the extra cost: In my opinion, definitely.

Oh, a note yet: I am an occasional techno fan.
For without a subwoofer, both systems are at low volume ne nice thing, possibly the small Bose pair a tick is there even better.
But as soon as it gets a little louder, the Bose pair is no longer with the Samson system.
The bass of Samson pair does already looks very impressive. But if you want to be massaged by Bass, needs a subwoofer or larger woofer.

Related Reviews


Best Sound to good priceEDIFIER S530D 2.1 speaker system (145 Watt) with infrared remote controller and wired controller, white (Electronics) 4.3 stars, very good sound, especially for the price!Grundig GSB 500 Bluetooth Speaker (Electronics) Top sound for a good pricePhilips SHB7000 / 10 Bluetooth Stereo Headset (1.2 m cable length)) Black / Red (Electronics) Great sound very good price / performance ratioDenon PMA 720 AE Integrated Stereo Amplifier (aluminum front panel, ECO standby, Advanced HC Singele Push Pull 2x 85 Watt) (Electronics) Sound good, look good, good price!Onkyo HT S 5205 5.1 Home Cinema System (HDMI, 1080p upscaler, 100 watts / channel) (Electronics) Good smartphone at a very good price-performance ratioHTC Desire 816 smartphone (13 megapixel camera, 12.7 cm (5.5 inch) touchscreen, 1.6GHz, quad-core processor, 8GB memory, Android 4.4) Meridian gray (Wireless Phone) Good quality at good price 2AmazonBasics High-Speed ​​HDMI cable (Ethernet, 3D, and Audio Return) 2 m (electronic) Top Podukt with a very good price ratio Listingbestbeans "Flashmop" wireless (wireless) Mini Bluetooth Speaker with NFC - Soundbar over 8 hours of battery life and mobile phone handsfree for Apple, Android, smartphones, PC, Laptops, Tablets universally (Electronics) Good price / performance ratio 5HP Envy 4500 e-All-in-One Printer (scanner, copier, printer, 1200 x 600 dpi, WiFi, USB 2.0): Smartphone and Tablet Printer - black (Accessories) good price / performance ratio 125Logitech Z906 5.1 Speaker System THX and Dolby Digital (electronic) Bass-biased headset at a good price / howlers freeSonixx X-Touch Wireless Bluetooth Headphone / Headset with touch control, microphone and remote control for all smartphones (iPhone / iPad / Android / Windows / Samsung Galaxy / HTC etc.) - 3 year warranty - German Manual (Black) (Wireless Phone Accessory) Mouse with good price / performance ratioUping® Ergonomic Mouse Mice Mice Mouse Wireless Wireless The cordless wireless mouse High Precision Optical with Side Control for PC and Mac, 4 Adjustable DPI Level 2000 CPI, 6 buttons, 18-month battery life, nano receiver setup (black) (Electronics) Top Monitor with good priceBenQ GL2450HT 61 cm (24 inches) Height adjustable LED monitor (110mm height adjustment, HDMI, DVI, VGA, 2 ms response time, speakers, Pivot) black (accessories) Good price, good performance - what more could you wantFANTEC QB-35US3-6G 4x 3.5 inch HDD Enclosure USB 3.0 & eSATA (Personal Computers) Receiver class and good priceDenon AVR-X2100W 7.2 surround AV receiver (WLAN, Spotify Connect, Internet radio, 7 + 1 HDMI in, 2HDMI Out, DLNA, AirPlay, 150 Watt) (Electronics) Good price with quirksHumax DVR-9900 C Cable Receiver (160GB hard drive, certified for cable Germany, MPEG-2, SCART) (Electronics) Very good - Good price / quality ratioHP H2800 Headset Black (Accessory) A very good price / qualityCoppertech® Wireless Bluetooth Speaker 10W compatible with iPhone, iPad Air, Mini, Samsung Galaxy S5, S4, HTC, Tablet, PC, Grey (Electronics) Very good price / quality ratio 161Plantronics Gamecom 380 integrated PC Gaming Headset Microphone 3.5mm Jack Black (Personal Computers) Good price / quality ratio 631Novero Rockdale Bluetooth Headset Black (Electronics)