Gothic 1 was torn, because you had to choose a faction and you had to walk much and the battle system has been controversial. In Gothic 2 you had said to speak too much and Gothic 3 was indeed so full of errors that it could only be saved through the use of very dedicated fans by means of a Community Patch.
Now in Gothic 4 is already grumbling again - but this time wrongly!
The game is graphically a superb and it is m. E. error-free! The dialogues are short and concise, and logical. The game is hard enough at level normal, so I'm desperate sheer in some places, especially in the beginning, the gold is in short supply and you can buy little potions! I liked the game very much and I did not regret to have bought the game on Amazon at full price!
Of course, I have a few points that I did not find as nice as the same old faces, which are very well modeled and also lip-synched talking. What had annoyed me was the pop up window if you searched the defeated enemy, because you have so switch to a key combination such as in The Witcher to the things to take automatically.
The bottom line is I recommend every role player not to be making crazy and buy the game! You will not regret it!
The fun I would have given 0 points prefer, because the game is not funny, nor should be! Actually, I find this unnecessary additional rating!