For server applications clearly better suited than the Raspberry Pi

For server applications clearly better suited than the Raspberry Pi

Banana Pi board 1GB RAM (Personal Computers)

Customer Review

The Raspberry Pi unfortunately has a major weakness, which you will only understand if the device is fully configured and ready for its use:
2 (B) / 4 (B +) of the USB ports, and Ethernet Controller are connected via a (!) Common USB Lane, which is also implemented as a USB-OTG. All connected USB devices and the Ethernet controller must divide the theoretical throughput of 480 MB / s (USB 2.0, gross) among themselves. By implementing a USB OTG USB operations are partly outsourced to software, bringing the already weak CPU of the Raspberry Pi is an additional burden.

If you want to RPi as compact, energy-saving server for home NAS, as or use the access point for similar I / O-intensive applications, you inevitably come across the problem of low throughput: more than 20MB / s (net) are hardly possible. If Ethernet and USB ports claimed alike (as in the case of a NAS or AP), so the rate is even lower.

This problem has the Banana Pi in the expression is not: It is true that here the two USB ports are connected through a hub, which they share the bandwidth, but the USB is designed here as a host. Furthermore, the Gigabit-Ethernet controller is connected separately to the CPU.

With the appropriate adapter cable (not included), a 2.5 "hard drive can be connected via SATA to Banana Pi. The power is also supplied via the device, thus no additional power supply is needed.

The selection of images is now plentiful. In addition to the well-known from the Raspberry Pi "Raspbian" (a Debian Fork), various Linux distributions, an Android and an OpenWRT image available. The Raspbian image comes - as opposed to the original - with pre-installed LXDE desktop and additional software. A minimal image would have been nicer.

Anyone wishing to use a Pi * as a server is so secure better off with the banana pi. The significantly stronger dual-core CPU, the doubled RAM, the high throughput on USB and Ethernet port as compared to the RPI and the presence of a SATA interface for 2.5 "hard drives predestined BPI for these purposes. For Mutlimedia applications it is - despite powerful GPU - currently less suitable by the lack of hardware acceleration.

For control and tinkering, the Raspberry Pi is recommended. The bulk of the additional hardware is developed for this board and work on banana pi only partially. The active community that will help in case of problems, does the rest.

Super 622 Rank: 5/5
November 30
Great Lok! Rank: 5/5
April 13
Good and cheap 132 Rank: 5/5
January 26
Toulouse O !!! Rank: 5/5
November 1
Comfortable and attractive Rank: 4/5
July 11

Related Reviews


For PC better suited than other adaptersCA-156 Nokia miniHDMI / HDMI adapter cable (electronics) Makes better pasta than the expensive sisterKenwood A936 pasta attachment (household goods) Replacement for my S110 with better image quality - the assessment of non-professionalsCanon PowerShot G7 Digital Camera X (20.2 megapixels, 4.2x opt. Zoom, WiFi, NFC) (Electronics) Better reception than the originalUniversal rod antenna for cars 16V, 38 cm Better performance than the standard model with KäfigkauglichkeitLucky-Kitty Drinking Fountain for Cats quality pump with power supply (Misc.) A better quality than the original strapSony 1288-5828 (Electronics) Better quality than the "compatible"Samsung MLT-D111S Toner original (Office Supplies) Probably better quality than the old XP SeriesKrups EA 8250 fully automatic coffee machine Piano (1.8 l, 15 bar, 1450 Watt, steam nozzle) black (household goods) Suitable for all Leatherman, which are greater than the JuiceLeatherman MOLLE Holster II XL (equipment) SATA USB no better than the Raspberry PIOpenSource Barebone Banana Pi (Cortex A7 Dual Core, 1024MB RAM) (Personal Computers) Better feel than the originalatFoliX Screen Protector for Apple iPad - FX antireflective: Screen Protector Anti-glare! Highest Quality - Made in Germany! (Accessories) Makes a better impression than the original partCabin air filters activated carbon kit for BMW 5er E39 looks better suspect than the price leavesIKEA NOT uplight in black Better performance than the price suggests.10m Network Cat.5e RJ45 patch cable gray LAN DSL (Electronics) Worlds better than the Raspberry PiSunFounder Banana Pi mini PC Open Source Motherboard - A7 Dual Core / 1GB DDR3 / HDMI CVBS LVDS / RGB (Electronics) Better experience than the competitionLogitech G240 Gaming Mouse Pad Cloth (Accessories) Very effective, very fine and better protected than the version Pro1DCircular polarizer filter Ø77,0mm series HOYA HD (Accessory) Perfect shell for LG G2, which costs less than the postage!Me Out Kit FR TPU Gel Case for LG G2 D802 - black frost printing (Wireless Phone Accessory) Better light than the original halogen lamps4X MENGS® G9 Dimmable 5W LED lamps & bulb lamp with ceramic body (350 lm, warm white 3000K, AC 220-240V, 360 ° viewing angle, Ø18 × 48mm) Super energy-saving light-good for heat dissipation