good CPU cooler, imposing and silent

good CPU cooler, imposing and silent

Thermalright Macho MACHOREVA Rev. A CPU Fan (Accessory)

Customer Review

Cooler came to replace a 212 evo whose original fan began to show signs of weakness.
In my case, it must be cooled to an i5 3570K 4,4Ghz even 4,6GHZ.

It was announced difficult to install: in fact, no! little more than another cooler.
This is done quite simply but effectively without the screwdriver provided this had been the original cotton!

For a first installation, it is more reasonable to leave the motherboard of the case. To be mounted / dismounted at least 6/7 times over the cooler to maximize spreadability of thermal paste (arctic MX-4), one can also mount it, leaving the motherboard in the case (ATX). You just remove the graphics card.

Regarding the space left to ram my Z77A-G45, the first slot is almost unusable for the ram equipped radiator. So I use the slot 2 and 4 as was the case with the 212 evo.

A beautiful baby this macho-HR. But it is bulky which is not without consequences.
- The most interesting: it can withstand a semi passive operation at frequencies "reasonable" processor using just the ventilation of the case. Impossible with smaller models.
- Another good thing, because of its eccentric structure, the back of the macho is less than 30mm fan placed at the bottom of the case. The set allows to enjoy this housing exhaust fan to create a push / pull effect.
- The push pull, exactly. Because of this proximity to the fan placed in the bottom of the case, a real push / pull with a second TY-147 (25mm thick) would not be viable. It is therefore understood better than the Macho is delivered with 1 single mounting kit.
- A contrarian point of now. With long enough graphics card circulation in the case is less efficient than that with a smaller cooler (evo 212). Thus Macho do not actually manage to make the difference in pure performance with a muscular 212 evo (a push pull with 2 swif2 120P) unless they have a well ventilated case and perfectly organized (no cables impeding airflow ). Once optimized / ventilated temperature gain ends up being this: in 4,6GHz with macho: 73.5 ° C on average over the 4 cores, against 74 ° for the evo 212 with push pull swif2 (80 ° C with 212 evo "stock"). 0.5 ° C less just? Yes, but the noise gain is far more important as thoroughly TY-147 is much more discreet.

Note: to win again 1.5 ° C with the macho, I have put my graphics card on the second PCI-E3.0 port. Ok, but then the graphics card that is not PCI-E x16 x8 but. GPU performance loss rather low 1 to 6% for what I've experienced: Not serious but annoying.

The TY-147 fan: a 140mm model, which is a plus compared to macho equipped with a 120mm fan. There is a flow of air which passes over the motherboard always good to take for the ram and above the power stage. The TY-147 is particularly effective. It blows a bit weaker than swif2 120P but is much quieter (than 1300 RPM to 1800 against the background swif2)
The model had produced a strange noise of friction: damage. As always excellent service Amazon offers a quick solution. 1300 RPM If not enough, there is the TY-143 to 2500 RPM but the noise is not at all the same :).

Finally, a cooler at an extremely attractive price (only 40 euros!), No more difficult to install than the number of CPU cooler. It is primarily intended for those considering (or who leaves the possibility) to overclock their CPU generously while maintaining a very good noise / performance or those who appreciate the security of semi passive mode in case of failure of the fan .
Otherwise, without overclocking consider, cooler master 212evo will do just as well with the same quality of silence and 10 less. At worst, if you change your mind, 10 saved can help achieve an excellent push pull equally effective but far more noisy!

The right way Rank: 3/5
October 18
Good set for testing Rank: 5/5
December 8
My first Tablet ... Rank: 5/5
July 23
Perfect 1491 Rank: 5/5
January 29
perfect 1 3261 Rank: 5/5
August 2
Practical and effective ... 25 Rank: 5/5
February 14

Related Reviews


Exceptionally good CPU coolingbe quiet! BK013 Shadow Rock 2 CPU Cooler LGA 775/1150/1155/1156/1366/2011 / AMD 754/939/940 / AM2 + / AM3 + / FM1 / FM2 (4-pin) (Personal Computers) Good CPU cooler, a little noisy under full loadCooler Master V8 CPU Cooler (RR-V8VC-16PR-R1) (Accessories) Good quality / price ratio and silent.Seagate BARRACUDA 03250 3.5 internal hard drive "1000 GB serial_ata600 7200 rev / min (Accessory) Good CPU coolerBe Quiet Pure Rock 11xx / 1366/2011 / FMX / AM2 / AM3 / FMx- Cooler (Accessory) Good CPU cooler, but beware AMD AM3 (+) - base-User!BeQuiet! SHADOW ROCK SLIM BK010 CPU Cooler (Personal Computers) Good almientation well cable and silentTechsolo STP-650 Power Supply 650W ATX PC (Accessory) Cooling well and silentlyZalman FX100 CPU heatsink without a fan for Socket 1150 / FM2 / AM2 + / AM2 / AM3 + / AM3 / FM1 / 775/1156/1366/1155/2011 (Personal Computers) Corsair Vengeance and space for CPU cooler?Corsair Vengeance 8GB Black (2x4GB) DDR3 1600 MHz (PC3 12800) Desktop Memory (CMZ8GX3M2A1600C9) (Personal Computers) Quiet, strong and high quality. An excellent CPU coolerbe quiet! BK019 Dark Rock Pro 3 CPU Cooler (accessories) Compact, good housing, and good value, cooling and space and beautiful details and facilitiesAerocool PGS QS-200 Mini-Tower, Micro ATX (Accessories) Quiet and efficient CPU coolerbe quiet! BK009 Skirt Pure CPU Cooler (accessories) Good, quiet - keeps the CPU coolScythe Mugen 4 - processor cooler, SCMG-4000 (Personal Computers) Cool design and good materialCURVER LITTER, CAT TOILET HOUSE - color WHITE 51X38.5X39.5 - TOP QUALITY !! (Kitchen) CPU with good price / performance ratio and good overclocking potentialAMD Phenom II X6 1045T processor box (2.7GHz, Socket AM3, 1MB Cache, 95 Watt) (Personal Computers) Good speed, good construction but imposing size and above HS in 5 months ...Kingston DataTraveler Ultimate 3.0 32GB USB G3 USB 3.0 Metal (Personal Computers) good battery life and silentPhilips - QT4023 / 32 - Beard Trimmer 3 Days, accuracy: 0.5 mm (Health and Beauty) Stylish design, high quality finish, convincing cooling performance - and the whisperBeQuiet! SHADOW ROCK SLIM BK010 CPU Cooler (Personal Computers) Super Cool, powerful and quietARCTIC Freezer 13 - processor cooler with 92mm PWM fan - CPU coolers for AMD and Intel sockets up to 200 Watt cooling capacity - Multkompatibel- With voraufgetragener thermal compound MX-4 (Personal Computers) Very good perf - cooling / noise / priceCoolink SWiF2-120P Case Fan (Personal Computers)