It's just not a GTA ...

... I think this game really awesome and for me it beats even GTA 4! As a fan of the first hour of GTA RDR was a must for me, as it is for me nothing more beautiful than an open world game.
And here we come to the issue: it is not just GTA. Anyone who thinks / thought here it's off as in Liberty City, which had previously time to watch a Western. Helicopter with a rocket launcher from the sky get (and similar things) is of course not in it, but this game thrives on the atmosphere of the infinite and the Wild West. And I'm glad you here sometimes has a bit of peace and can enjoy the game while at GTA 4 constantly someone called and wanted to do something about (and then was insulted when canceled).
That the dialogues are in English I like the joke and the atmosphere always get lost in synchronizations (unfortunately), have until now any movie / game experience that the German was better than in the original English.
The story is well done and exciting, the characters are great (only the sayings of Herbert Moon at poker in Armadillo)
only the end was a little surprising, but fits into a typical Western.

An absolute buy recommendation for Western, US and nature fans. All that should be on wild banging, spectacular explosions, chases in sports car and escapes by helicopter rather play GTA 4.
Thumbs up for Rock Star!