Long-term experience, bad!

Long-term experience, bad!

Western Digital WD10EARS Caviar Green 1TB internal hard drive (8.9 cm (3.5 inches), 5400rpm, 8.9 ms, 64MB cache, SATA) (Accessories)

Customer Review

As this drive came on the market about 3 1/2 years ago, it was among the most fuel-efficient as eco-drive and only 5400rpm, yet was reasonably fast 90MB / s. Finally, I then decided due to the 2010 for 1TB low price of 69 for this plate.

Bought 14.05.2010: (unfortunately not directly from Amazon)

-> As of mid-2011:
I have used them mainly as a data grave (2.Platte), thus are my frequent performance issues noticed after about a year. The start-up time due to the power saving mode of the hard disk is now stopped 13! Seconds. The tugs especially when document, photo or video editing on the nerves when with every automatic save the program hangs for 13sekunden!
Would that my system disk, they would long since kicked out, but I have simply no time to nearly 1TB of data back up search, especially since no alternative was location!

-> As of mid-2012:
Meanwhile, I have massive access problems with the disk. At times she herself was detected in BIOS let alone the Win 7 workstation. I was afraid my entire data is lost (no backup - how stupid) ... but the change of the SATA II connector on the board needed remedy .... for now. After only two weeks, the problem occurred again and caused system crashes and data corruption. Fortunately I have now secured my data externally. Unfortunately, I find the receipts no longer :( ..... but a complete formatting for the time being managed again Remedy.

-> As of early 2013:
I have now bought a Seagate Barracuda 1TB as a system disk and mirrored all data. In addition, I have your receipt FOUND (3 years warranty)! Meanwhile, the drive writes only with 40MB / s of former 90MB / s, sad!
After the write noise of Western Digital "Ökoplatte" which actually were so quiet and economical to, despite decoupling even be heard in the next room and the board at least once a day bogged down (scratch with loud) and reboot the system enforces, I've had enough ,
This plate I entrust no more data!

-> Conclusion:
If I had earlier found the sales slip again, the plate would long since wandered back. I will not buy any more Ökoplatten!
And I've learned from my mistakes -> the new Seagate I bought from Amazon so that I can turn to someone in trouble!

-> Recommended:
No! ... I can dissuade you from this board only. Let's see how the exchange model, but I have. To the problems actually do not feel like Current panels of WD I can not judge, but I recommend you buy a Seagate. My system disk (Seagate 250Gb) has held with no problems 7.5 years!

Regards, Maximilian

Eigendlich good workmanship Rank: 4/5
December 16
Original strap Rank: 4/5
January 28
El diablo Rank: 5/5
May 2

Related Reviews


Long-term experience (since D-Release)Microsoft Surface Pro 128GB with Windows 8 (10.6 "ClearType Full HD display, 16: 9, Pen Input (included), 3rd Generation Intel Core i5 Processor, Intel® HD Graphics 4000, 4GB RAM, WiFi, Bluetooth) (Personal Computers) Long-term experience HQ W9-20195HQ W9-20195-HQ Electronic Water Detector (Misc.) From long-term experience highly recommended!5 filter cartridges suitable for fully automatic coffee machines from Bosch® Siemens® AEG® Krups® (household goods) Good product with beautiful light, convinced so far down the line. Long-term experience will be exciting!Steinel LED house numbers light XSolar LH N silver, illuminated house number incl. 1200 mAh Lithium-Ferrum battery, monocrystalline solar panel, 007 157 (household goods) Long-term experience permeated ...Roccat Ryo MK Glow Illuminated Mechanical Gaming Keyboard (MX Key Switch black) (accessory) Long-term experience - failure too early ...SEBSON® GU5.3 MR16 LED lamp 3W 220lm (Replaces 25W) [Warm White - SMD LED bulbs - 110 ° viewing angle] (household goods) Long-term experience / tips / update OS 10.3.1BlackBerry Passport Smartphone (11.4 cm (4.5 inch) display, nano-SIM, QWERTY, 32GB of internal memory, 13 megapixel camera, BlackBerry OS 10.3) Black (Wireless Phone) No long-term experience10 x Original Gold Lippenpads Baviphat® - plumping of the lips by hyaluronic acid by Baviphat® (Misc.) Long-term experience 2SIGMA PC 25.10 heart rate monitor (equipment) It bubbles and bubbles and bubbles, our long-term experience ...SodaStream Soda Cool (with 1 x CO2 cylinders 60L and 2 x 1L PET bottles), green (household goods) Long-term experience = NegativeSilverline 336004 measuring tape with automatic lock 5 m (tool) Long-term experience LadyCup LLadyCup menstrual cup L Gross St 1 (Personal Care) Long-term experience 1Sony Micro Vault Midi Click 8GB USB (Personal Computers) Long-term experience rather negativeDyson Digital Slim DC35 Multi Floor Handstaubsauger (with 2 suction levels, 200W electric brush with carbon fibers, 22,2V) metallic (household goods) The long-term experience is still pending ...Silit Allegro non-stick pan flat without lid Ø 28 cm (household goods) Long-term experience, lousy!WC seat with soft, high-quality surface, easy installation, sturdy hinges, Star Tripes Positive long-term experience with a birthday presentCasio Wrist Watch Digital (Textiles)