I use the mascara now since mid-August and am unfortunately only moderately satisfied. The color is indeed great, the volume - in my opinion - rather mediocre. But what I have to criticize above all, is the durability. Once you sweat a little trickles of mascara extreme. Furthermore, the application is rather impractical by the more liquid texture. I give the mascara 3 points, because the result is quite ok and I - had very inferior Mascaras - for this price.