Not compatible with the basic game made of wood!

Not compatible with the basic game made of wood!

Cosmos 6950190 - The Settlers of Catan Cities & Knights (Toys)

Customer Review

Already 13 years ago we spent long evenings in good company with the settlers of Catan. At that time, however, only with the base game and indeed in the wood version.

Since my son has reached the age Catan, the game was finally brought after many years in the past month once again out of the closet. In times of xbox360 and PS3, the settlers have not lost their charm and also my son is excited about this. A nice Christmas present in the form of the two settlers extensions (sailors and Cities & Knights) was thus found quickly.

Yesterday then -As always occurred vorbildliche- delivery from Amazon. But what I found out?!? The two games are extensions -Why not whatsoever- compatible with our basic game of wood, tells me the back of the cardboard!
"I have read about some in the product description?" was my first thought ... No, I did not! Not a word is mentioned that the extensions do not let them play with the wooden version.

So what to do? A quick glance at the calendar tells me that we have the December 20 today and that it could be a nerve-racking task, if I send back the two extensions now, I'm thinking about a new gift and me again to the pre-Christmas fray throw ...

OK, the Bench I will have to throw anyway to get the basic version made of plastic ...

As has apparently not changed at the game principle but a different kind of game material is responsible for the incompatibility, I assume that the manufacturer thereby once again like to make a few extra euros. For this rip-off and for me the worries I forgive 1 point !!!

Ps: Settlers of Catan base game (1998) deliver the highest bidder ...

ADDENDUM 1:
The friendly customer service of the cosmos has promptly responded to my complaint. It is possible to get directly from the publishers free a framework of Seefeld. So then, the extension with the old edition is playable.

ADDENDUM 2:
Unlike the Seafarers expansion -for which I have- I really have liked a slightly larger extent with the Cities & Knights expansion fully satisfied. New game elements such as the defense of the island against the barbarians, or a 5-step expansion of the cities bring enough variety to the game. By-called urban expansion also come a variety of new development cards are used and also the cities themselves can now be provided with ramparts and expand to a further stage to metropolises.
Not to be forgotten is the dealer. This is -as already put the Raiders in Basisspiel- on the resource fields, but brings a positive effect, because this raw material is now available in a 2: 1 can be exchanged with the bank (provided you have in the immediate vicinity of a settlement or city).

For the good and quick support of the cosmos and the great playability is now earned 5 stars from me. Who plays with the idea to add itself only an extension to the settlers, which I would definitely recommend this here. It provides, in my opinion the best price / performance ratio!

Diversity Rank: 5/5
April 9
great album !! ac / dc, yes !! Rank: 5/5
December 27
perfect 1 6739 Rank: 5/5
September 8
right product 3098 Rank: 4/5
August 6

Related Reviews


Varied innovation for Settlers fans, only compatible with the basic game of the 2nd generation, not with extensionsKosmos 693 411 - The Settlers of Catan - explorers and pirates (Toys) Attention NOT compatible with the Nikon D5100M & L Mobiles® premium quality Battery EN-EL14 like Nikon (Electronics) Not compatible with the Alpha 77 - Camera does not recognize the flash.Yongnuo Speedlite YN-560 II flash system / Camera Flash Sony Alpha DSLR etc. - New version with an LCD display for Sony Alpha A850, A550, SLT-A35, A37, A57, A65, A77, etc. (electronics) Fine, but not compatible with the USB 1CSL - Mini key / dongle Wi-Fi / WLAN (Wireless LAN) 300 Mbps / WPS button (automatic integration into the network) | MIMO | WPA2 | compatible with Windows 8 and Windows 8.1 (Electronics) Not compatible with the LG G2, but good sellerKosee Qi Wireless Charging Station Intelligent compatible with Smartphones Brands LG G2 G3 Moto X Nexus 5 Nokia 1152 Nokia 928 (See the description for the complete list of compatibilities) (Accessory) Not compatible with the Blue YetiSAPS01 Samson PS01 Anti-Pop Filter (Electronics) Is not compatible with the Orange LiveboxBelkin N300 Dual Repeater F9K1111as universal WiFi 2.4 GHz / 5 GHz (2x150Mbps) - White (Personal Computers) good but not compatible with the detector KiddeIdprotect IPR336000 Set detector for mounting (Tools & Accessories) Is not compatible with the Parrot Zik 2PF056001AB Parrot Parrot Zik Headphones Battery for Black (Electronics) Not compatible with the Parrot Zik Headphones 2.0PF056001AB Parrot Parrot Zik Headphones Battery for Black (Electronics) Good product but bluetooth not compatible with the PS4Techmobility - Gamechair - Gaming flesh with 2.1 USB speaker Black (Personal Computers) not compatible with the lg g3NILLKIN Magic Disk: Wireless Induction Charger Universal IQ (Samsung Galaxy S4 Google Nexus 4, Nexus 5, LG Optimus Vu II, Nokia Lumia 920, Nokia Lumia 925 ...) (Wireless Phone Accessory) not compatible with the samsung s5Patuoxun ®Chargeur Office Dock Station with true USB 3.0 for Smartphone Samsung Galaxy S5 SV i9600 (Electronics) Not compatible with the latest IpodsJVC RV NB 50 Stereo Radio recorder (CD / MP3 player, FM Tuner, 40 Watt, Apple iPod Dock, USB 2.0) Black / Silver (Electronics) The adapter is not compatible with the 81310 Miniflex Book Light. This was not apparent in the description.Mighty Bright Mighty Bright Europe Power Adapter 81310 (household goods) Great device, not compatible with the newer MacBooks!Apple Remote (optional) Do not buy if the basic game was purchased through Steam.Watchdogs - Season Pass [PC Uplay Code] (Software Download) Unfortunately, not compatible with the 2014er model of Macbook Air 11Tkoofn® ultrathin Crystal Hard Case Cover Protective Hard Case Cover notebook sleeve Hard Case for Apple MacBook Air & MacBook Pro - Incl. Cloth bag (11 inches - MacBook Air, Black) - PT9000 (Electronics) Not compatible with the listed OEM power suppliesNotebook Power Adapter AC Adapter Charger for HP Compaq Mini 5102 HP Compaq EliteBook 2540p 2740p HP Compaq Envy 13 14 13t 14t compatible with 381090-001 384019-001 391172-001 463958-001 519329-002 ED494AA ED494AA # ABA PPP009H PPP009. With Euro power cord. From e-port24® (Electronics)