This book is readable, though for my taste, the end is disappointing. I too probably compares this book with the Scottish trilogy by this author, which I loved. Here we still have the atmosphere of the islands, plus canada. Back in return that I like but not the magic which I was accustomed. I recommend this book any time that remains. For cons, I just go on the books of this author on China and I am very pleasantly surprised. In short, for me, it remains a super good writer!