Polishing yes or no, and especially what for what?

Polishing yes or no, and especially what for what?

Messerabziehpasten Set: 10ml POLISHING + 20cm leather straps (Misc.)

Customer Review

Despite many positive opinions for polishing the cutting edge with knives I am (what practical use in the kitchen relates to) come to exactly contrary results compared to those of several Mitposter.

Spiegelblank not necessarily is also advantageous.

It may be so, the high-gloss polishing of the cutting edge for the morning shave his chest hair with a machete (And let's be serious - who has been a need for an ultra smooth shave his pork roast or who barbiert a stilt) in the country / moral area for carving with the Taschenfeitel or the breaking of ungulates by specular cutlass edge brings an understandable advantage - which I can not check. What, however, in the kitchen and in the preparation of foods such as fish, meat, vegetables means to allow me an opinion.

And this is: Shaving a forearm across the easily detectable by a blade human hair stand differs vastly from the tough rind claim an autochthonous pig roast to cut. The can be quite smooth and resistant in the raw state. This approach offers little space for a razor.

Especially those under magnification easily recognizable, 'Micro-saw edge' which quality abrasives such as the so Sauteurs as highly effective Spyderco Tri-Angle Sharpmaker (bought here on Amazon) leaves on the cutting edge of the blade is only the decisive gripping bite.

It may be that a polished edge is theoretically much sharper, but this razor quality can not be in the cooking practice use. A blade for the morning shave and Armhaaren (as is often praised as the ultimate track record) may be perfect, slipping on smooth surfaces around rather helplessly and miserably failed hardest test, the incorruptible paper towel test. Try for yourself, either with or without polished edge:

To cut a piece of crumpled paper towel in slices -
or
- To divide a very ripe tomato using only the weight of the knife.

You will be amazed at what results you are (/ after Loriot before) come:
Before polishing the traditionally sharpened blade, the blade was still strong zubeißend, after polishing to smooth surfaces far less - however, if one takes after polishing the knife a few times over the ceramic rods of Spyderco, thereby roughening (the original state restores) , you get the full 'bite ability back.

PS: A little polish to the degree to break is of course advantageous and perfectly acceptable, but polish to full splendor is unfavorable for the kitchen practice - the amount makes up the poison.

But the polishing paste has a very different, very effective application:

When scratch knives this is ideal for removing damage, to mitigate or to turn dull metallic surfaces those in which you can reflect (with some difficulty). For small diameters and hollow cuts and rounded blade hardware has a natural cork with the circular a little paste is rubbed, proved to be more effective than to pull the entire knife on the prepared leather.

PS: for raising the level of the cutting edge after the "honing" you do not need to paste leather - the gentle, repeated stroking a Stove Wooden done that in passing - free.

Figure in 100x magnification - very cutting joyful snappy knife edge Sharpmaker sharpened with the Spyderco - without polish.

Price performance super 11 Rank: 5/5
February 4
not listening Rank: 2/5
October 21
Expensive but "lifesaving" Rank: 4/5
December 1
Very very good 33 Rank: 5/5
November 6
Super couscous! Rank: 5/5
August 31

Related Reviews


The best and versatilste Webcam that I know of in this price range, even and especially for MAC OS XD-Link DCS-942L Day and Night Home Cordless IP Camera (Accessories) Very good bridge camera also (and especially) for the casual photographerCanon PowerShot SX50 HS (12.8 megapixel, 50 -x opt. Zoom (2.8 inch display), Japanese Import) (Electronics) Very good value for money and especially back seat to the road up to 13 kgBritax Car Seat First Class plus, Group 0 + / 1 (birth - 18kg) Black Thunder (Baby Care) A tip device, inexpensive and exactly what I was looking for!Fujitsu LIFEBOOK AH502 39.4 cm (15.5 inches) notebook (Intel Pentium 2020M, 2.4GHz, 4GB RAM, 500GB HDD, Intel HD, DVD, Win 7 HP) matt black (Personal Computers) For fans of Disney and especially STITCH !!!!fun cute original design STITCH 8GB USB blue (Electronics) very thin and no description no leather at all especially good for winter leather motorcycleTangda Motorcycle Leather Jacket Man Jacket Winter Coat Jacket Casual Fashion (Clothing) Am satisfied, UV and especially the iris is needed for the FZ72UV, Polarizer, grille, cover and sunshade 55mm for Panasonic Lumix DMC-FZ72 FZ 72 (DK00B55mm) (Electronics) Especially cool and useful accessories for Apple Bluetooth KeyboardMobee MO3212 The Magic Bar - inductive charger for Apple Wireless Keyboard (Personal Computers) Excellent for architecture and landscape, good for family photos or reportageSony Alpha 6000 system camera (24 megapixels, 7.6 cm (3 ") LCD display, Exmor APS-C sensor, Full HD, high-speed hybrid AF) black (Camera) Good, fun, ... and with room for improvementStreet Level (Audio CD) A real tablet with a protective shell and ergonomic, suitable for baby.Vtech - 147905 - Electronic Game - Touch Pad Storio 3 Baby With Shell (Baby Care) Not bad, but not the miracle announced by some. Especially suitable for typical listening "sono".SMSL SA-98E Amplifier 2x120W TDA7498E T Digital Car Amp with Power Adapter (Silver) (Electronics) Not bad, but not the miracle announced by some. Especially suitable for typical listening "sono". 1SMSL SA-98E 160w * 2 TDA7498E HiFi amplifier / digital digital stereo amplifier with 85% efficiency for birthdays, parties, concerts, music at the supermarket etc. (Electronic devices) PLC adapters especially designed for extended housesDevolo 9298 - Powerline Adapter Pack 2 (dLAN 550 + duo starter kit): 2-port Fast Ethernet / integrated telephone socket (Personal Computers) High quality and especially with applications running (Viber, Google Maps Navigation, etc)!Plantronics Bluetooth Kits M 70 - English, German (Accessory) given the low consumption and especially no mercury in it !!!IDACA 2 x Led Bulb E14 60 * 5730SMD 15W 220V 550LM Led Spotlight Lamp Cool White (Kitchen) Very good epilator accesories and VERY helpful (for once!) But BEWARE THE BATTERY !!!Philips - HP6581 / 00 - Epilators - XL Satin Perfect Wet & Dry 6-in-1 Ceramic Head (Health and Beauty) Jablonsky and Transformers together for the fourth time!East: Transformers (Audio CD)