poor image quality, stress with Java on Mac, no poe

poor image quality, stress with Java on Mac, no poe

D-Link DCS-5222L / E mydlink Wireless Internet / Security Camera black / white (Personal Computers)

Customer Review

Those looking for an IP camera with pan / tilt / zoom, does have a huge selection, but few devices in the area to 200 euros can match the performance of her with an actual webcam. the D-Link 5222L is a candidate. it promises pan / tilt / zoom with a resolution to 1280x720 points. built is still an infrared LED, with which can be included in b / w night. I wanted to use the camera via the web interface on Apple Mac, and by Surveillance Station on a Synology NAS.

Install & Setup

The hardware installation is quick and easy: power supply and (optional) Insert the Ethernet cable ready. is Power over Ethernet is not supported, although this is claimed on some sites on the Internet: the way. that's annoying, because the length of the power supply cable to the sets range to the next outlet. the camera consumes less than 15 watts, according to labeling, would be suitable for PoE.

Unfortunately, the software setup is a pest. At first I tried to set up the camera via WiFi, which worked with either the built-in (invisible), still with the accompanying stub antenna. also the WPS button did not fotrtschritte along with a Fritz box. only via a network cable and by chance I finally came up with the built-in web interface. The problem is that the camera seems almost a minute reboots if you have changed settings. During this time, you do not know whether the operation was successful. the whole setup took me almost an hour and a few nerves.

Picture & codecs

Camera has four channels for various image formats and qualities that can be selected by four numerical keys in the web interface later. they are not fully adjustable, so is intended for a small screen as the 3rd channel of the jpg-stream and the 4th channel. the 1st channel can be compressed codecs (zbh264) also set at the highest resolution, which should of course allow the best frame rate with respect to the lower volume of data to be transferred. Furthermore, one can choose some quality parameters for the compressed streams.

the first disillusionment came when viewing the live image in the various settings: Image quality is namely miserable! the image noisy, despite the HD resolution is grainy and seem a kind of blur effect exhibit: appear around edges a kind of corona. the internet I found the tip, the front of the lens ring lock the focus. which is otherwise apparently not documented and must be found by trial and error (especially great when you have the camera installed near the computer). the picture is really a corner better but remain the fundamental problems. each 50-euro-HD webcam makes a much better picture!

Next check: the "zoom" function is digital, ie the already poor image is a cutout via digital magnification 2x or 4x zoomed. as you can imagine, enhances the image quality in any way, on the contrary.

really annoying it is on Apple Mac, if you want to use one of the three channels except the jpg-stream. you namely a current (and therefore safe) Java7 installation, you see ... nothing! this Java installation is not supported by the camera on mac. so you need to either escape back to an older, less secure java6 installation or to a PC. the jpg-stream otherwise functions without problems, unfortunately (due to lack of compression) up only in low resolution.

control

via the web interface, the camera can be rotated horizontally and vertically adjustable in steps. it works quite well on the control keys. Anyone who wants can save specific positions and recall them at the drop-down menu. even a kind of patrol function is present in the back and forth between two positions and is hergeschwenkt.

More functions

The camera can of course also various other functions such as microphone and (external) speaker, motion detection and recording. even two external connections can be exploited, for example, for a separate lighting. Recording is done on an optional mini SD card, for a slot on the housing available. All this I have hardly tested, since I currently do not need these functions.

the night vision function works quite well within a radius of a few meters. one should be careful not to let the camera look outward a window if you want to use this feature, because the disc reflects the IR light, so that you can see nothing.

Operating on Synology NAS

out of interest I have the camera eingereichtet times under the Surveillance Station Synology DSM my NAS. the idea was to drive monitoring with motion detection and recording on the power-saving NAS. The decor is basically quite simple, because the camera is already supported in the current DSM version. Unfortunately you have to give here on channels other than the jpg-stream. The same applies for (but also unusable) Zoom. the pan (pan / tilt) funkioniert unfortunately only in four directions, and not, as in the web interface of the camera, and in the four intermediate directions (eg "right"). Another drawback: while the Surveillance Station is running, turn the plates no longer starting. So nothing save electricity. I got this off given trial because he did not produce the hoped-for benefits.

Conclusion

the most important in a camera is the image, and that is bad in the DCS 5222L. But why? Logitech Unveils example excellent USB webcams ago to 100 euros, the Spitzenbild deliver an even at twilight. Why you can not connect to a motor controller and a small computer board such a thing? for the other functions is the D-Link Camera pale. The decor was extremely complicated to me, the requirement of an older Java frustrating and risky for Mac users. so the camera is unfortunately a disappointment and with just under 200 euro too expensive. therefore points from me just 2.

Update 16/08/2013: D-Link provides its own ncs driver who is also the operation of the encoded three streams on Mac allows. Unfortunately, this seems to be flexibly programmed that he always exactly the residual power from the system absorbs that is still available. For example, the load is on my quad core Mac Pro at 250% (ie overloaded 2.5 kernels fully off). as long as the stream is displayed, you can work with the computer just as "tough" call. unfortunately unusable.

Again very successful master mix Rank: 5/5
January 23
A ring with washer Rank: 4/5
November 20
Not good 36 Rank: 1/5
November 27
Avoid 320 Rank: 1/5
October 1
well received but 2 Rank: 3/5
May 6

Related Reviews


Strangely assembled box whose biggest shortcoming is the poor image qualityDepeche Mode Live in Berlin (Audio CD) very poor image qualityDepeche Mode Live in Berlin (Audio CD) Convenient and solid, but poor image qualityKodak Playsport Pocket Camcorder Zx5 Port SD / SDHC 5 Mpix Digital Zoom 4x Waterproof Black (Electronics) Good design and functionality but with poor image qualityPanasonic Lumix DMC-ZX3EG-K digital camera (14 megapixel, 8x opt. Zoom, 6.9 cm (2.7 inch) display, image stabilized) (Electronics) Compact camera with a lot of gimmicks and poor image qualityNikon Coolpix S6400 compact camera (16 megapixel, 12x opt. Zoom, 7.6 cm (3 inches) touch screen) Blue (Electronics) poor image quality with a lack of !!! brightnessPanasonic DMC-SZ3EG T Lumix Digital Camera (6.9 cm (2.7 inch) LCD screen CCD sensor, 16.1 megapixels, 10x opt. Zoom, 90MB internal memory, USB) chocolate (Electronics) Evening repeatedly misfires, poor image qualityAmazon Fire TV (Electronics) Brilliant image quality, problems with the durability and quality controlCanon EF-S 17-55mm 1: 2.8 IS USM lens (77mm filter thread, image stabilized) (Accessories) Not suitable for children + poor image qualityEasypix Aqua W318 Bubble Bob Bubbles underwater digital camera for children (3 megapixels, 8x opt. Zoom, 4.6 cm (1.8 inch) display) (Electronics) Explanations for the poor image qualityRollei Bullet 5S 1080p Outdoor Edition (action, sports and helmet camera) (Equipment) extremely poor image qualitySony HDR-CX240 HD Flash Camcorder (Full HD, Exmor R CMOS sensor, 2.2MP, BIONZ image processor X) (Electronics) poor image qualityRollei Sportsline 60 Digital Camera (5 megapixel CMOS sensor, 8x digital zoom, 6.1 cm (2.4 inch) display, waterproof up to 3m) (Electronics) Unfortunately very poor image qualityWedding Camera "White Rose" - pack of 10 disposable camera with flash (27 Rec 400 ASA.) (Electronics) Top things in robustness, image quality sometimes with defectsOlympus TG-3 Digital Camera (16 Megapixel CMOS sensor, 4x opt. Zoom, WiFi, GPS, waterproof to 15m, cold-resistant, dust / shock and shatter-proof) with F2.0 Lens (Electronics) Negative Rating often unjustified because of poor image quality.Humax PR Fox C MK II Digital Cable Receiver (with SKY card reader) Silver (Electronics) ... Image quality but with grainatFoliX Protection Film Screen Sony Xperia Z1 Compact - Set of 3 - FX-Antireflex antireflection (Wireless Phone Accessory) Beautifully compact, but Selfiefunktion class poor image qualityPanasonic DMC-W SZ10EG Lumix Digital Camera (7.5 cm (3 inch) LCD display, MOS sensor, 16.1 megapixels, 12x opt. Zoom, WiFi, 80MB internal memory, USB) white (Electronics) Many shortcomings and poor image quality SDPanasonic TX-47ASW754 119cm (47 inches) 3D LED backlight TVs, EEK A ++ (Full-HD, 1200 Hz BLS, Smart TV, Twin HD Triple Tuner, DVB-T / T2 / C / S2, CI +, Dual Core Plus, SAT> IP Client, WLAN) Silver (Electronics) Great features, ease of use, high image quality and with touch and WIFI on boardSamsung WB250F Smart Digital Camera (14.2 megapixels, 18x opt. Zoom, 7.6 cm (3 inch) LCD screen, image stabilization, Full HD video, WiFi) cobalt (Electronics)