Smart versions, but not very racy finesse

Smart versions, but not very racy finesse

Symphony 9 (CD)

Customer Review

I am more and more attentive to production chief Michael Schonwandt 62 years which certainly is very good in the Nordic music (Nielsen are fully reflected) but who we leave a beautiful ring with his Royal Danish Orchestra.

The future head of the opera of Montpellier (the langedossiens can rejoice) is less known in France but is recognized by the addition rhin concerts that he gave for his wonderful leadership of Beethoven, Brahms, Schumann, Bruckner and Mahler to name chef. I would add also check-Strauss published by Chandos his Salome with the Danish Radio (which have changed names but that is the same Quici orchestra) and ranks alongside the best-Karajan, Solti, Leinsdorf-no small feat .

Finally, we have a chance to hear one of the Titans attack late Romantic repertoire, a job that is certainly a candidate for the title of greatest symphony of the 20th century.

He leads the Danish National Symphony Orchestra, orchestra and high quality that is exactly right to leave the wealth of its rich gloss for this music and the virtuosity required in this work.

First hitch for a disc of the 21st century, the symphony is spread over two discs while the total duration is of slightly less than 80 minutes.

The recording was made in the new Copenhagen Concert Hall and is made from live in 2012.
The recorded sound is excellent almost bordering the beautiful, spacious sound pickup and detail-even if it does little to prevent some parasite noise even if this audience is very acceptable and infrequently.
9th Mahler differs from Bruckner's 9th in the fact that Bruckner anticipates the terrifying ordeal of death followed by judgment, with the hope of salvation and eternal life.

Mahler is rather bitter, and tell the vagaries of inevitable fate of man, also doing ironically as in all his symphonic work, and ending with a nihilistic resignation and expiry
Schonwandt is the fastest side of the spectrum interprétatif.La driving through the neuroses of the first movement emphasizes the dramatic oeuvre by the side keeping the momentum and especially with a fairly flexible beaten and extraordinary changes in tempo, very fast in middle section and is a bit too fast for me in the 2nd "funeral march", but it nevertheless remains an effective understanding.

There are minor problems of sets and narrowly-momentary, with some inaccuracy but not exactly spoil the first two movements, but prevents produce a full effect, a full consistency. Fortunately, in the nightmare world of the symphony, vagueness is almost inevitable (consider the superb live recording Bernstein BPO, where among the misadventures seffondré a member of the audience struck by a heart attack so that the clips have absent (not played) during a major input, but copper group ensured and performance is one of the finest recordings left), and recovery is quick.

The second movement also begins dryly, away from the tread reading Klemperer and OPV, so the tempo change is less surprising, but it is the right play superbly Inist highlighting all comically dramatic momentum. Also really beautiful demonic waltz.

The third movement is at the side of tempo perfectly what I'm looking, dazzling virtuosity and orchestra glory of covers in this movement with precision and very mature especially in stamps (especially the horn).
The final did not train and Schonwandt portamento and rubato widely applied, so that this section, the more intense the Symphonieen avoiding extremes that reveals very effective is beautifully played at any point.

So in the end this is a very late registration and a superb performance, with minor reservations about the technical accuracy of very local way that does not suffice to exclude very very good versions, and certainly confirms that the head has much to tell us about Mahler.

Obviously the competition is fierce and we can not recommend this version as a first choice are the versions of Bernstein (Berlin and Concertgebown), Giulini, Sinopoli (excellent, my favorite avev Bernstein Concertgebown).

Start a wonderful trio History Rank: 4/5
February 21
Backache ade ' Rank: 5/5
October 15
Combi pack 32 B Rank: 3/5
April 2
compliant products 1 Rank: 2/5
February 18
Buy 3 validated Rank: 5/5
April 20
perfect 1 9023 Rank: 5/5
May 16

Related Reviews


Good but not very thickCanvas background fabric 100% pure COTTON (2.8mx1.8m) Green for chromakey Photo Video Studio photography 140g / sqm (Electronics) good quality, comfortable but not very feminineBirkenstock Gizeh 0436 Bk, Tongs femme (Shoes) small but not very fastSanDisk Cruzer Fit 16GB USB SDCZ33-016G-B35 (Personal Computers) Good quality but not very practical0038X888 Canon Soft Case DCC-1920 for Digital Photo Black (Accessory) very well initially but not very reliableP10CB Samsung car charger (Wireless Phone Accessory) Very good but not very strong.Nike Air Zoom Vomero 7 Running Shoe Foot (Clothing) elegant hull, but not very pleasant to the touchOwnstyle4you Soft Case Hard Case For Samsung S7390 Galaxy Lite Trend Glitter Silver incl. Screen Protector and Stylus Pen (Electronics) pretty but not very functional with towels behind the door.The distributor Zinc towels, Behind the Door But not very aesthetic magniableDaffodil WMS500L 2.4GHz wireless mouse with mini USB receiver and adjustable DPI, powered by 2 AAA batteries (included) - Color Blue (Electronics) Solid but not very stable.ELTD Ultra Slim Case Cover for Asus MeMO Pad Tablet 7 ME572C (For Asus Pad MeMO 7 ME572C, Black) (Electronics) beautiful cushion, but not very paddedCushion Sol Rouge 40x40 cm Reliable battery lights for outdoor use, but not very brightMr Beams 35 lm wireless battery-powered LED bollard with Beweungsmelder for outdoor use, 2-Pack, Black MB572 (tool) Amusing but not very providesWild Animals (Paperback) Solid, but not very surprising conclusionInto the Still Blue (Under the Never Sky Trilogy, Book 3) (Paperback) Works, but not very stableDVBSky S960CI USB Box with DVB-S2 tuners and CI Common Interface Slot for PayTV, USB 2.0 (Personal Computers) Prima LED strip, warm white, but not very bright. Solid power supplySET: LED STRIP WARM WHITE 5 meters IP65 (wassefest) - Incl. PSU / 300 LEDs / strip / tape Funny Gag but not very suitable.Lurch 70077 Wassereisbereiter Flutschi Set of 4 (Kitchen) The large version is not very prettyHama Spiral Album "Fine Art", 36x32 cm, 50 pages, apple green (household goods) Not bad but not very goodMantona Laurum 501 Multi tripod camera tripod incl. Lamp tripod, monopod, tripod table and ground-level Tripod with Ball Head (Accessories)