Too many mistakes and errors ...

Too many mistakes and errors ...

Philip the Fair (Hardcover)

Customer Review

Georges Minois presents here a real biography of Philip the Fair could have been an excellent book, beautifully documented and presented chronologically (and not by themes such as that of Jean Favier).

This book has it all ... But the mistakes made by the author when he speaks of currencies (one of the big issues of the reign yet) are unforgivable. It confuses parisis Books and Books tournaments converts without any rigor, and mixing the currency of account and the metal species so that its calculations are thereby totally distorted. This facet of the work that has yet -to tort- earned its reputation as the King "counterfeiter King" has been neglected or even sloppy. Georges Minois has clearly not read a line of masterful "Monetary History of Medieval West" of Étienne Fournial.

Another drawback, which greatly lowers the quality of this book is the huge number of mistakes othographes, shells and substantive errors that dot this book (one example among others: "The bishop Guichard handed released in 1313 [...] dies in his native Champagne in 1307 "(sic!)); unforgivable mistakes in a book whose language is meant to clear and precise and widely scattered with excerpts (not translated) into French of the thirteenth century.

Finally, Georges Minois would do well, I think, to read as soon as the copy and make necessary fixes do ... if only out of respect for its readers who bought the Kindle version of the book.

Related Reviews


Everyone complains because too many stems and small itemsBB.UMSS.N - Limited Special Edition (2 CDs + DVD + T-Shirt and Poster) (Audio CD) Too many cords and bucklesJack Wolfskin Rucksack Moab Jam 24 (equipment) too many stickers and 3D imagesSimba 105957618 - Filly Ice Unicorn Unicorn Advent more on a skating arena 2011 50 x 31.5 x 5 cm (toys) It works without problems should not be too many obstacles and still a little slow reactionPhenix YCX-2000 2 radio controlled outlets outside (Tools & Accessories) Too many cable and all front connectors on the head; under Win 8.1 not reliable in my PCAkasa AK-ICR-17 Internal USB 3.0 Card Reader (3x USB card reader, USB port and 3 USB 2.0 HUB) black (accessories) Too many mistakesChess for Dummies (Paperback) Disappointed, too many mistakes ...Breviary failures (Paperback) Generally very good, but too many mistakesNintendo Wii U Premium Pack black incl. Mario Kart 8 (preinstalled) 32 GB (console) Loses much too many down and zipper is too small and hookedMarc O'Polo women's short coat 308 0329 71123 (Textiles) Too many functions and poor instructions.Casio - AQW-101-1A - Sports - Mixed Watch - Quartz Analog - Digital - LCD Dial - Bracelet Resin Black (Watch) Too many quotes and Wikipedia article BUT REALLY SUPERMy shooting-guide mounting: more professional light your HD productions (Paperback) For too many purposes and may therefore only partially suitable for the use of tools.3M Gripping Material, 25 mm x 2 m, Grey, 635 288 (tool) too many mistakes in recipesThe desserts that make me crack (Paperback) LONG VERSIONS ...? just some good here .... but too many album and single versions ... totally disappointing !!!Disco Long Versions (Audio CD) Also offered for the price too little or too many mistakes.Kamor® Protector Google Nexus 7 2013 Case Case Google Nexus 7 2 Case Cover Leather Case Shell Hard Case Cover Accessories Google Nexus 7 FHD Case Carrying Case with Stand Function / Auto Sleep Wake up with Stylus (stylus) -PU leather, Black (Personal Computers) Too many bugs and failuresGigaset DX800A corded hybrid telephones with voicemail and integrated DECT base station, analog, ISDN, VoIP (ALL-IP) (Electronics) Realistic but too many mistakes reduce the fun!Fight Night Champion (video game) Far too many mistakes !!Fallout: New Vegas (Video Game) Ok, but too many mistakesIn Nomine (Paperback)