I have read the product reviews and despite some negative reviews decided to buy the shell. I have no regrets. The cover fits snugly and is secure, question without being too tight. Thickness is OK. All Eingaänge and buttons are accessible to it except the SIM / XD card opening, but since you do not want to actually also. I do not know if the magnetic charging works (some have criticized) - that I have not tried yet. So far, at any rate strong buy recommendation!