The book presents case that the author then develops his professional filter. It makes changes of pace and sometimes surprising style a little unsettling but give the whole a pretty nice human side. It does not require the reader to join his remarks to enjoy the developed ideas. I liked the positive view of depression as a transitory moment revealing and an opportunity to advance. I hang much less the idea of the DIP or that everything goes back to childhood wounds.
I preferred the passages that show the link with the contemporary social functioning and felt a certain contempt for those who dismantle other forms of proposed therapies (apart from the changeover on Psychotropic which proves very fair when we had the opportunity try to). While it is true that these drugs aggravate things by anesthetizing the individual and preventing him from enjoying the opportunity to repair his being, so I found the transition quite shabby on the work of "therapists" (he puts itself in quotes, starting with a fairly low number of insults and not substantiated) quoting practices that I personally found particularly effective as food approaches, CBT. I find it unfortunate that the author was not aware that the long task of psychoanalytic kind (and very expensive) requires fast reliefs and practical approaches in parallel to work on his past. As for reducing behavioral therapies "I'm fine all is well" ... basically ... it's totally ridiculous.
In conclusion, this book is worth seeing. I found it exciting though with arbitrary bias (or even contempt charge). Moussa Nabati has an interesting thought, especially when compared to our social requirements. There has to take and leave but it would be a shame to miss. I think you have to approach it with a critical mind. I put it 4 stars because I never thought that one day a book could show me the psychoanalytic approach with respect.
