Yes, the music is definitely wonderfully old-fashioned; the sound, however superb. The vocal numbers convince almost entirely - only Norah Jones I buy the "Sophisticated Lady" not really from. The instrumentals convince me, as long as he keeps his horse in check on saxophone. In the second part of the second piece, and in the no. 4 they go but a little carried with him. Then it begins - to my mind - to annoy and the wonderful 30/40 / 50s night club feeling lost for a moment. The annoying thing is that this glitch occurs almost immediately after buttery opener of Melody Gardot. (That's why I do not 5 star). It's a matter of taste, whether you are on fast saxophone runs or not; virtuosity is quite sure.
Those looking for something special, for delicious moments for two but also alone, is certainly well served here. Autumn makes -schon on Nachmittag- for the right light.