worth the money, does what it should

worth the money, does what it should

AVM FRITZ! Powerline 520E Set (500 Mbit / s, Gigabit LAN, power socket) (Accessories)

Customer Review

Since I am a network administrator am an advocate of the network cable (robustness, reliability, throughput, latency, cost), I was initially quite skeptical about whether the adapter pair would be my requirements. At first it did not look good, as the adapter does not times the throughput from the cable provider (32 Mbit / s) were able to conduct. However, not this was due to the adapters, but to the attitude of my network card. Analysis with a packet sniffer showed that the flow control was active. When I disabled this in the properties of the network card, it looked a lot better.

In Windows 7, you reach this setting via Start / Network / Network and Sharing Center / Change Adapter Settings / right click on the appropriate NIC / property / configure / Advanced / Flow Control filters (flow control) to disable or deactivate. The flow control comes from old times in which TCP is not regulated the traffic.

Now I have already tested the adapter pair for several weeks under a variety of conditions in practice and over again. Since I do not much felt by statements a la "My Internet is slow." think, I have collected a few numbers for the experts. Before setting up the experiment, it is advisable to test several possible outlets and select the maximum data rate. Electricity consumers in the vicinity should be connected necessarily to the adapter because it contains a blocking filter, thus preventing the spread of disturbances on the power line.

-
Experimental setup:

Host A - Gigabit switch - Powerline adapter - about 40 m permanently installed power cable - Powerline adapter - Host B
Displaying transmit gross data rate Host A: swaying 100-210 Mbit / s
Displaying receive gross data rate Host A: swaying 180-260 Mbit / s
Firmware version of both adapters: 5.2.3-02

iperf with over 60 sec. measured data throughputs:
-----
100 Mbit / s (Green mode active):
A -> B 1 TCP stream: 54 Mbit / s
A -> B 10 TCP streams: 73 Mbit / s
B -> A 1 TCP stream: 59 Mbit / s
B -> A 10 TCP streams: 86 Mbit / s

with hrPING measured package runtime:
Packets: sent = 1000 = 1000 rcvd, error = 0, Lost = 0 (0.0% loss) in 499.508481 sec
RTTs in ms: min / avg / max / dev: 1,414 / 4,031 / 40,058 / 3,947

-----
1000 Mbit / s (Green mode inactive):
A -> B 1 TCP stream: 64 Mbit / s
A -> B 10 TCP streams: 78 Mbit / s
B -> A 1 TCP stream: 56 Mbit / s
B -> A 10 TCP streams: 92 Mbit / s

Packets: sent = 1000 = 1000 rcvd, error = 0, Lost = 0 (0.0% loss) in 499.508817 sec
RTTs in ms: min / avg / max / dev: 1,525 / 3,644 / 40,087 / 3,442
-
Power consumption measured by VOLTCRAFT Energy Check 3000 (measures performance from 1.5 W):
Standby: not measurable (active at 100 Mbit / s (Green mode): 1-2 W
active at 1000 Mbit / s (Green mode inactive): 2-3 W

The measurement results can be the following statements:
- Based on the maximum gross data rate of 500 Mbit / s is achieved about 15% (70 Mbit / s).
- The attainable net data rates correspond to approximately 50% of the specified in the software gross data rate.
- The adapters achieve nearly the performance of a Fast Ethernet connection (100 By / s).
- The signal propagation time is increased by about about 3 ms compared to a cable
- The signal propagation time is approximately 0.5 ms Gigabit under a Fast Ethernet connection.
- The adapters are very economical and together cause less than 5 electricity costs per year.
- The "Green Mode" (Fast Ethernet, 100 Mbit / s is of cost / benefit point of view the "not Green Mode" (Gigabit) is preferable because the disadvantages (slightly higher latency) from the advantages (lower energy consumption) predominate more than 100. Mbit / s throughput are always unrealistic.
- The adapters are worse than a cable connection (logical!) But better than any WiFi connection.

Some words on the operation:
- Plugging, work and forget.
- Updates are maintained by AVM.
- Software is not cluttered and easy to understand.

In short, yes, the purchase is worth it if you want to lay a cable. Even with the rather high price. For the average end-user devices are highly recommended and preferable to any wireless connection. Therefore, there's me ne strong buy recommendation if you can not lay cable.

Related Reviews


the device does what it shouldAccuPower APIQ328 fast charger with capacity display, discharge function, LCD display for AAA / Micro. Mignon / AA NiMH rechargeable batteries (optional) The filter does what he should.Neewer Infrared IR Lens Filter 58mm (Electronics) The Unkrautstecher does what he should, however, remain ...WOLF-Garten Unkrautstecher Automatic IW-A; 73AAA001650 (tool) The tool does what it should.TecTake® brake piston reset tool resetter Set piston reset tool set 22-piece blue The device does what it should, but the switch is dangerousEinhell RT-AG 125/1 Red Angle (tool) OK for the price - does what it should - ADDENDUM: DEFECTIVEJomo universal fill valve 'locus - pocus' cistern - valve The device does what it should, but ...Sanyo eneloop MQN04-E overnight charger (Accessories) The part does what it should!Olympus VF-1 optical viewfinder (Accessories) The shell does what it should, a little room for improvement.Goodstyle UltraSlim Case with Stand and presentation function V2 Case for Microsoft Surface Pro & Surface Pro 2, Black (Electronics) The battery does what he should.Battery for Samsung Galaxy S Duos S7562 (EB425161LU, EB-F1M7FLU, Li-Ion) (Electronics) The file does what it should doPfeilring glass nail file, 13.5 cm, clear (Personal Care) The handle does what he shouldNeewer® Battery Grip for Nikon D750 DSLR Camera Multi-Function Built-in 2.4 GHz wireless control vertical battery grip (Replacement for MB-D16) The splitter does what he should.Phobya 4Pin Molex to 6x 3Pin Splitter (Electronics) The flash does what he shouldNeewer® VK750 II-i-TTL Falsh Speedlite with LCD Display for Nikon DSLR D7100 D7000 D5300 D5200 D5100 D5000 D3200 D3100 D3300 D90 D800 D700 D300 D610 D300S, D600, D3 D4 D3S D3X D200 N90S F5 F6 F100 F90 F90X SLR D4S (Electronics) Good size - tricky in the attachment - does what it shouldLEIFHEIT reference BT Univer. 140x45 cm + cord clamping clip, 1 piece, sorted (household goods) The brush does what it should.Philips Sonicare HX9170 / 10 FlexCare Platinum Sonic Toothbrush, UV disinfection (Personal Care) The adapter does what he shouldAdapter 3.5mm mono plug to 3.5mm stereo coupler (accessory) The converter does what he should.KEJA, Digital to Analog Audio Converter - with power supply and toslink - Full metal - black (Electronics) All the best, does what it should.deleyCON HDMI Splitter / Distribution 4 Port - 3D Ready / 1080p - metal housing (electronics)