Becker vs.  Garmin

Becker vs. Garmin

Becker Ready50 LMU navigation device (12.7 cm (5 '') screen, 44 countries of Europe, HQ TMC, Text-to-Speech, Becker SituationScan) Black / Mocha Metallic (Electronics)

Customer Review

Have the Becker Prof. 50 (almost identical to the Becker 50LMU) and the Garmin nüvi 25xx LMT extensively tested both units corresponded theoretically my expectations, mainly because of the "lifelong" map update function.

100% final I have not decided yet; but I tend to very pure subjetkiv unit of Becker although the Garmin is as great Navi.

Specifically, the devices for me distinguished as follows:
- Very awesome is the power connector from Becker to the bracket. The device goes on and off with the ignition. When Garmin you always lying around the cable, the Becker Ready 50 LMU has not this active holder!

- Also requires the Becker TMC for no second antenna as the Garmin. one can thus attach something concealed fixed the current TMC cable. When Garmin you always have to connect and have the cable lying around,

- The pace of warning Garmin is a disaster! It starts at 1 km / h is exceeded and has a very unpleasant sound. This can be turned off and can be exceeding show visually, but you may also regulate better! Such as when Becker. Here you can adjust the allowable timeout for city and highway to the warning gentle Gong who does not bother really, even if it sounds more in succession. In Garmin forum I've noticed that a lot of users are very dissatisfied with the warning.

- Speed ​​Cameras warning vain way, there is not both; even if Garmin This suggested by the adjustment. No Blitzer was me appear at the traveled routes. You have to pay extra even, as in Becker. Just what it costs at Garmin is not so easy to find, as only a 30-day trial is offered.

- Very well, I found that the Becker is easily configured by the PC software on PC. What I noticed this additional positive price transparency for additional services is (POIs, city maps, etc.). Garmin doing a little secret around, does not fit the present day!

- The Satelittenerkennung was extremely fast and well by both devices - the unit of Becker, however, was the Garmin this respect a little ahead.

- Advantage even when Becker, it can be used for up to four users create their own profiles.

- The unit of Becker also offers more locales that are displayed by simple click: speed, permitted blood alcohol etc. That makes sense for trips abroad.

However, the Garminnavi also has its features that can keep readily Becker not so:
- It offers several "Cockpit Views" with lots of information such as floor height, direction, time, speed, permissible speed and distance to the destination and time of arrival.. Becker provides this information also, but at the same time you have to for max. 4 decide.

- The route calculation is extremely fast at Garmin. The display of waypoints on the top bar is a feature that Becker can not hold and which I find very good.

- Other benefits that Garmin is significantly smaller than the Becker and when navigating I realized that Becker has piloted me to a barrier for vehicles (which for 30 years there); Garmin has not chosen this route.

So it is very difficult here to make a decision. From Satelittenerkennung and the route selection both devices are sbsolut ok. As for little things and details must at all even know what is important and what is not.

Now you have and I want to make a decision. There are smaller device, against better pace Warner and especially practical Active Holder (to the Becker Ready 50 LMU also has not!). The other criteria are not so relevant, since both devices are very good in my view.

Probably I will opt for the Becker Professional 50.

Which also needs to be considered a point is: The 'Back' button of Garmin's digital on the screen, which is the Becker mechanically on the housing. When 'lifelong' update this could possibly be a 'breaking point' !?

Each device has pros and cons; finally you have to think what one is important and what is not; there are both very good Navis.

To Ask? I will answer you like as far as I can.

Watch all Rank: 5/5
September 14
Too slow 1 2 Rank: 2/5
August 18
Nice !! 1471 Rank: 3/5
October 27
Charger 2 USB ports Rank: 5/5
May 29

Related Reviews


Becker vs. Garmin - Great appliancesBecker Professional 50 LMU navigation device (12.7 cm (5 '') screen, 44 countries pre-installed, HQ TMC, Becker SituationScan, Lifetime Map Updates, OneShot voice control) Black / Silver (Electronics) Becker Professional 50 LMU / breaking point on the charging cableBecker Professional 50 LMU navigation device (12.7 cm (5 '') screen, 44 countries pre-installed, HQ TMC, Becker SituationScan, Lifetime Map Updates, OneShot voice control) Black / Silver (Electronics) Becker Support impossibleBecker Professional 50 LMU navigation device (12.7 cm (5 '') screen, 44 countries pre-installed, HQ TMC, Becker SituationScan, Lifetime Map Updates, OneShot voice control) Black / Silver (Electronics) Am satisfied with the Garmin nüvi 2569 LMT DGarmin nüvi 2569 LMT D CE navigation device (5 inches (12.7 cm) multi-touch glass display, Live Services, Smartphone Link) (Electronics) Well done Garmin!Garmin nüvi 3597LMT EU navigation device (12.7 cm (5 inches) touch screen, maps 45 countries in Europe, the whole of Europe, map update, TMC Pro) (Electronics) Swim - a reasonably priced Garmin GPS for without water - awesome to train counting and exercise recording - incl. Swimming stylesGarmin Swim Swimming-clock, black / dark green, swimming efficiency, speed, training functions (electronics) Garmin's new bike cadence sensor: light, easily, ingeniously simple! ANT + radio. No magnet, no adjustment necessary.Garmin Bike Cadence sensor 010-12102-00 (Electronics) Rip at Garmin AppKenwood DDX4021BT Moniceiver (VGA double DIN monitor, DVD, Bluetooth, Apple iPod-ready, USB 2.0) (Electronics) Protects my Garmin Oregon 450 wellUniversal bag camera bag for compact camera - eg Canon SX 260 280 - Sony HX50 HX60 - shell in black-green (Electronics) Service Quality GarminGarmin DVD City Navigator Europe NT 2011 (Software) Perfect service from GarminGarmin men, women bicycle computer (electronic) Modern navigation device from GarminGarmin nüvi 3597LMT EU navigation device (12.7 cm (5 inches) touch screen, maps 45 countries in Europe, the whole of Europe, map update, TMC Pro) (Electronics) Take good care of the Garmin Nuvi 2597 LMTNylon bag with optics suitable for Garmin 5.0 "(12.7cm) Navis as - nüvi 2595 LMT - nüvi 2545 LMT - nüvi 2565 LMT etc. - Black (Electronics) Garmin funzt againPremium Battery for Garmin Edge 605 / Edge 705 (1250 mAh) (Electronics) Pocket for my Garmin Oregon 650AmazonBasics Camera Case for compact cameras, medium size (Electronics) Garmin Oregon 450t reads the card properlyIntenso Micro SDHC 4GB Class 4 Memory Card incl. SD adapter (accessory) Keeps the Garmin bombproof.Garmin mount for bicycle; Oregon, Dakota, 62 series, Colorado, eTrex 20 eTrex 30 (Electronics) Good Naviagtionsgerät GarminTomTom XL IQ Routes Edition 2 Central Europe Traffic navigation system incl. TMC (10.9 cm (4.3 inch) display, 19 country maps, EasyMenu, lane assistant) (Electronics) 230V power supply Becker 50th Steckerlader 230V for Becker Ready 50 Series 50 ...230V power supply Becker 50th Steckerlader 230V for Becker Ready 50 Series 50 Active 50 Transit 50 Becker Ready45 Ready 45 LMU SE ICE - Charger 110-240 Volt (Electronics)