I drink for years the 15 year old Dalwhinnie and am a big fan of this gentle Scots. Now I've even indulged in the elderly. Maybe I've had for almost twice the price (54 instead of 32) a bit too high expectations. But I taste no difference. Optical me the darker label like better, but that's why I will not buy it again.
The Dalwhinnie deserves clearly 5 star !!! But it is (in my opinion) to identify any increase. Therefore, and the only reason why 3 stars !!!