Everything else is secondary for me. The gameplay is often referred to as "too simplistic" characterizes, I look at the following angles: it does not bother me. If I had been distracted from the story that is because of a stupid AI, unbalanced difficulty or bugs me would have very frustrated! Game Mechanical therefore it is quite above the average of what today passes for "Triple-A". Also, there is not a Survival Horror Online, where you should invest 200 hours therefore I think it's great that it is not too bad on the higher Schrierigkeitsgraden.
The design of the world creates a great atmosphere. Actually, I'm gamers quite Grafikhure. So I have to say that the graphics, they still do not like to be so great for the PS3, of course, is up to date (not on the "NextGen" consoles).
Special pluses there for the soundtrack: I have been staring never five minutes on the Start menu of a game in order to inhale the great atmosphere by the ears. I even bought a guitar and unceremoniously gerlernt exactly this a song ... sounds almost insane, if you like talking about it.
GIANTS MINUS not for the game, but for Sony's "Through exclusive title-buy-the-fool-our-old-rag consoles" strategy, which I put on a pedestal with DLCs and premium memberships. Under all! So have a PS3 gakauft and then beaten up again. That seems to be what Sony wants.