The third album by The National can match perfectly with the highly acclaimed predecessor "Alligator", and so the band could also be presented to the general public with David Letterman. Spex ruled aptly: "An album full of fine arrangements and clever lyrics that unfolds slowly Noble melancholy, dignified in speech and masterful in execution.." Most items are marked by strong melodies that are likely to impress only when repeated listening. Of course, rather slow and matching the incredibly beautiful-deep voice of the lead singer, no dance music. Not too moody how at first glance my like a par title might be a little too soft. If not boring despite Brawling and down listening.