D5200 D5100 VS

D5200 D5100 VS

Nikon D5200 Digital SLR Camera (24.1 megapixels, 7.6 cm (3 inch) TFT display, Full HD, HDMI) Kit incl. AF-S DX 18-105 mm VR Lens (Electronics)

Customer Review

I have long wondered whether I should treat myself to the D5200, because actually I am very happy with the D5100 and D5200 which is not a bargain level. Over a period of 12 days I tested both cameras under absolutely identical REQUIREMENTS extensively.
As a "test lens" I have the Nikon 18-105 VR and the Nikon 50mm 1.8 used. As memory card SanDisk Extreme Pro 95MB / s came 32GB used.

The sound of the D5200 is from ISO 100 to up to ISO 3200 only very very slightly better than the D5100, from ISO 6400 then the D5100 was ahead. The D5200 has a higher image detail loss as the D5100 and its advantage in 24 MP could play the D5200 100 and good weather only at ISO.
The handling of the camera has been improved. The thumb rest is something "catchy". In addition, there is now an additional button (including single image / frame advance) on top of the case. Some menu items under the camera menu (functions) have been extended. Since the video function is rather unimportant for me, I have not tried this. The build quality is absolutely identical to the D5100 - so great! The focus areas and cross-type sensors are now as in the D7000 in the viewfinder, so there is no small "red dots" more. However, I could not convince really the new autofocus system. Despite the significantly more existing cross-type sensors / measuring fields, I found the results of the D5100 something convincing !!! Very positive I found the new round dial on the camera back (very good pressure point - taken over by the D7000).

Due to the extremely large image files 24MP arise. In the D5100 has a JPEG image file size of approximately 4.5MB and a RAW file size of approximately 14,7MB. In the D5200 a JPEG image has a file size of approximately 8,1MB and a RAW file size of 22,3MB. So (JPEG FINE + RAW) fit on a 32GB card in the D5100 945 images and 612 images in the D5200, 32 GB are therefore almost compulsory. Do not forget also that the data transmission due to the large amounts of data takes on a PC (despite the extremely fast 95MB / s) for very long. With regard to the continuous shooting speed I could not really notice a difference :(

The previous speaker wrote ..... is much much better than the D5100, this opinion I can not confirm that. Due to the 24 MP I had hoped for a clear image quality advantage, which unfortunately did not occur. The image quality of the D5200 is to ISO 3200 are identical and from 6400 even slightly worse than that of the D5100. I also realized that the tripping times were slower, despite the new image processor (Expeed3)! The well 300, - Euro additional costs (410, - Euro 720, - Euro) for housing are justified under any circumstances, so I forgive "only" 4.5 stars. As long as the price of the housing will be about 550 euros, I will certainly not change or have to wait rather on the successor to the D7000.

I have two pictures (Winterimpression / winter landscape) set.

18:01: The transmission via WLAN adapter works super easy and very fast, also NEF files are transferred in full size! I tested the transfer on iPhone5 and Samsung Galaxy Tab2 10.1 32GB!

14:03: And I gave myself and it was a right decision. The picture quality is, as already mentioned, very good, (I'll have a higher ISO value probably never use) analogous to D5100 to ISO 3200. In retrospect, I can say that the new autofocus system with 39 focus points and the 9 cross-type sensors is a significant improvement. VERY IMPORTANT: Be sure to buy a high quality, ultra-fast SD card, such as the Sandisk with 95MB / s. The D5200 actually supports this speed, unlike many other more expensive DSLR's !!! Compared to Sandisk with 45MB / s I could see a distinct difference - really. Purchase price in early March 629, - in photo shop. Greeting Thomas

26.04: Another quite important note regarding the 24MP. Due to the very high resolution you should consider that camera shake is very large necessarily. The "old" rule focal length x 2 clearly no longer enough! With a focal length of 105mm (eg 18-105er lens) is often enough despite Image Stabilizer no longer a shutter speed of 1/200. Since the 24 megapixel "together are" very close it is quite fast to a superposition of the pixel; times simply put! My recommendation, for example, at a focal length of 105mm (KB157mm) a shutter speed of 1/400 LEAST, better still 1/640 despite image stabilizer, then the images are certainly (also in the enlargement) rattenscharf) To this day I am still very very happy with the D5200. Greeting Thomas

10:06: The following lenses are used and are highly recommended:

Nikon 18-105mm VR,
Nikon 50mm 1.8,
Nikon 40mm Micro 2.8,
Nikon 55-300mm VR (already much better than the 55-200mm VR and only slightly more expensive).

For best results, but clearly brings the 40mm Micro and then the 50mm 1.8.
To date, there was no problem with the D5200.
Used UV Filters: Hoya HD - very good quality but a bit pricey.

Related Reviews


Bag for example. Canon 100D 1100D 700D 650D 600D Nikon D5200 D5100 D3200 D3100 camera bag DSLR or system camera with accessoriesNylon Camera Case Black Universal (Electronics) Good overall performance with very good photo qualityNikon D3200 SLR Digital Camera (24 Megapixel, 7.4 cm (2.9 inch) display, Live View, Full HD) Kit incl. AF-S DX 18-55 VR Lens (Electronics) Battery Grip for DSLR Camera Nikon D5100 / D5200Battery Grip for DSLR Camera Nikon D5100 / D5200 (Electronics) Switching from Nikon D5100 D5300 onNikon D5300 Digital SLR Camera (24.2 megapixels, 8.1 cm (3.2 inch) LCD, Full HD, HDMI, WiFi, GPS, AF system with 39 focus points) Kit incl. AF-S DX 18 55 VR Lens (Electronics) Great replacement for D5100 and D7100 good alternative toNikon D5200 Digital SLR Camera (24.1 megapixels, 7.6 cm (3 inch) TFT display, Full HD, HDMI) body only (Electronics) fast shipping and the battery provides up to date on quite well .... in a D5200NEW !! For Nikon D3100 D3200 D3300 D5100 D5200 D5300 and Coolpix P7800 P7700 (incl. Update 1.3) !! Bundle Star * Patona premium quality battery for Nikon EN-EL14 EN-EL14a - Intelligent battery system - (real 1050mAh !!) "latest generation" (electronics) Nikon D5200 SLR VRII with kit lens 18-55Nikon D5200 Digital SLR Camera (24.1 megapixels, 7.6 cm (3 inch) TFT display, Full HD, HDMI) Kit incl. AF-S DX 18-55 VR II Lens (Electronics) From D90 to D5200Nikon D5200 Digital SLR Camera (24.1 megapixels, 7.6 cm (3 inch) TFT display, Full HD, HDMI) Kit incl. AF-S DX 18-105 mm VR Lens (Electronics) A grenade at the Nikon D5100! Dringene buy recommendation!Tamron AF 70-300mm 4-5.6 Di VC USD SP digital Lens for Nikon (Accessories) Very good ball head for D5100SIRUI K-40X tripod head (aluminum, height: 125mm, Weight: 0.7kg, Loading capacity: 35kg) Black with Removable TY-70S (Electronics) Great Tripod for D5100 and Sirui K-40XManfrotto tripod 055XPROB Pro (2 extracts, capacity up to 7 kg, 178.5 cm height) black headless (Accessories) Powerful battery for my D5100Nikon EN-EL14a Li-Ion battery for D3100 / D3200 / D5100 / D5200 / D7700 / D7800 (electronic) Perfect for Nikon D5100AmazonBasics IR remote release for Nikon Digital SLR Cameras (Camera) Also works with the D5100 and P7100AmazonBasics IR remote release for Nikon Digital SLR Cameras (Camera) Perfect for Nikon D5100 1AmazonBasics IR remote release for Nikon Digital SLR Cameras (Camera) working immediately with my Nikon D5100Bundle Star * Quality Battery for Nikon EN-EL14 - Intelligent battery system - 1030mAh - for - Nikon D3100 D3200 D5100 D5200 - Coolpix P7100 P7000 (P7700 to Update 1.2) (Electronics) Nikon D5200, battery work after firmware update C1.01Bundle Star * Quality Battery for Nikon EN-EL14 - Intelligent battery system - 1030mAh - for - Nikon D3100 D3200 D5100 D5200 - Coolpix P7100 P7000 (P7700 to Update 1.2) (Electronics) At D5100 and D5300, the sun rises on acousticTascam TM-2X (Electronics) Case and Battery for Nikon D5100Kit Mantona Premium Systemtasche + NEW !! Bundle Star * Patona premium quality battery for Nikon EN-EL14 EN-EL14a - Intelligent battery system - (real 1050mAh !!) "latest generation" for Nikon D3100 D3200 D3300 D5100 D5200 D5300 (electronic)