I you recomande great with these three very easy to function reliably over the chein comprent e react faster and better to tone it conprent that vibrate little and get thatthe electric shock is a very eficasse so avoid charging the necklace well maintenance charge load a single time in a month yet put in charge for months | 5 stars for u avoire the first branded schoolboy who had a fontion shock q I do not regraitte my new dog dressage NIOHC of super stop