Disappointing compared to Volume 1.

I was rather seduced by the Volume 1 of the tape Renaud. I enjoyed the dust that had allowed me to listen to modern texts on cooler orchestrations. So it is not without pleasure that I bought volume 2. And there, what a disappointment!
The voices crush the music, and what a voice! Ok, we can not say that Renaud is a voice singer, but he's a poet who lives his texts, which raises the stack where you have words. But in this album, what a disaster! Music in the background, atrocious voice (Vincent Lindon .. Ohlala, this is not the tribute that! It is a pity!).
One has the impression that it is the voice that give rhythm to musicians. It's totally fine with the Calogéro and Olivia Ruiz, not too bad with Nolwenn Leroy and Lavilliers a bit with Nicolas Sirkis, but not at all with others !! This is false or cutesy, as desired. We even have a false note in the computer editing the piece of Emmanuelle Seigner ...

In fact, it is worthy of a TV dinner "tribute to Renaud" with Drucker, when friends come to sing.

However, I found a gem on this album: the interpretation of "the blue" by Calogero is just sublime.
Such a bonus point for Olivia Ruiz surprised me with a beautiful "Farewell kitten" extremely well dusted.

2 extra songs on the album 15, disappointing !! You have to admit, everyone can not be a poet-performer. I almost believe it