Does not keep anything that is promised

Does not keep anything that is promised

Geiger counter radiation gauge wheel rate Basic (Electronics)

Customer Review

Wheel rate is according Intenetangebot supposedly can measure alpha particles.
However, this is proven to not be the case, you take the evidence:

From the welding accessories, while a WT20 TIG electrode diameter 1.6mm, length: 175mm, which are the red with the mark and 2% thorium content.
At 6 g electrode weight ie 120 mg thorium. Natural Thorium has a specific activity of 8120 Bq per gram.
The electrode thus 974 Becquerel (counts per second)
The electrode is broken into 2.5 cm pieces, the pieces are close to each other glued to a wide tape.
In this radiating surface of 2,5x1,1 cm you put exactly wheel rate-count window, and one via tally sheets for 10 minutes, the pulses.
This results in 24.22 cpm (counts per minute).
That this is so little compared to the 974 rays per second, according to this source produces its thorium content, easy is because most alpha particles can not leave the tungsten rod.
Only - and yet, after all: 2% of all the atoms in the surface are 232-thorium atoms whatsoever Emmi animals the way the decay to next Alpha one gamma ray. In the other decay series are roughly gelich many short-lived alpha as beta-emitters. 232Th makes half of the alpha + gamma thorium activity, the other half comes from the short-lived isotope 228Th.
But further in the test:
We push a strong paper (250g / m2) between our thorium-alpha source and the wheel rate-count window, and again 10 minutes count the pulses:
No Change! Still 25.6 cpm, this time even in between a little more than paperless.
And that means that wheel rate does not count alpha particles,
otherwise it would be significantly less impetus now because:
Already a sheet of paper shields alpha particles completely.
Now we take a acrylic sheet of 3 mm thickness in between, which is suitable for alpha and beta radiation intercept:
Reducing the count rate to 5.44 cpm - what then is only gamma radiation,
80% of the measured wheel rate of radiation was beta, and possibly additionally the bremsstrahlung of beta emission at Wolfram.
This corresponds very roughly even a proportion of total emissions of gamma and beta over the entire decay chain from 232Th, and thus makes the attempt in addition plausible.

Criticism:
1. It is promised, which is not to keep: wheel rate does not measure alpha radiation.

Although 2nd wheel rate has a counter, but serves to limit apparently only to the duty (self shutdown after 10 min). There is no indication of totalized pulse count, or another counter display.

3. The Auto-off after 14 minutes is annoying if you want longer count.

4. That no count output is present, is disturbing, because the "flackerige" display that integrates seemingly through a capacitor, and finally outputs the voltage is only useful from about 10 - 20 events per minute,
which then already corresponds to 10 to 20 times the background radiation.

5. The price is a bit high, because there are comfortable equipped detectors similar power already for 40 euros less,
or even for only 40 euros as a kit.

5. The battery clamps so strong that the battery actually only by opening the housing also gets without violence and tools again - only marginally worth mentioning probably it is even necessary that the battery is stuck, and can not be moved in order to avoid microphonic missing pulses ,

Compliment:
1. wheel rate measures beta radiation quite well, and apparently also gamma radiation.
2. The packaging is good, the delivery prompt and professional, the service I can only judge in a few days,
because I'm still waiting for the answer to questions about the technology.

Suggestions:
If you open the case, is actually still a lot of space inside for a better and more accurate pulse counter,
the detection electronics deserved safely. And without the daily radioactive contamination in foods with wheel rate can not accurately measure. But even a reset button with adjustable measuring time (1 day - 1 week - infinity)
Or at least one counter output and a gamma spectroscopy with the original signal from the detector ...
----------------------------
PS / edit: Limiting the duty cycle can be eliminated on the front of the board by desoldering the jumper J3. My wheel rate now also has an additional RCA socket as counter output on the front ;-)

Scbuss in the oven Rank: 1/5
November 17
Good but long ... Rank: 4/5
January 11
ATTENTION! 1112 Rank: 2/5
July 16
compliant filter Rank: 5/5
October 27
super !!!! 1880 5102 Rank: 5/5
October 29

Related Reviews


Does not keep all what is promisedAEG 222 167 Huz 5 eco DropStop small storage, 2 kW, open 5 liter undercounter storage, pressure (tool) A product that does not keep its promises and instead falls within the electronics student prototypeiClever® Wansview NCH-532MW mega pixel HD Waterproof Surveillance IP Camera with Night Vision Outdoor WiFi 8mm lens IR CUT Infrared (Electronics) Product an attractive cost that does not keep its promises over timeEx-Pro High Power Fuji Finepix NP-50, NP50 - 2 year warranty, Replacement Lithium Li on Digital Camera Battery for: - Fuji Finepix F50, F50fd, F50 fd, F60, F60fd, F60 fd, F100, F100fd , F100 fd, F70EXR, EXR F70, F200EXR, F200 EXR (Electronics) Very nice design, but does not keep all its promises!Bodum Columbia 1308-57 cafetiere, double wall, 8 cup, 1.0 l, stainless steel (houseware) Provisional: All ok, but does not keep all its promises (volume)Western Digital Hard Drive 1TB WD1003FZEX (8.9 cm (3.5 inches), 7200rpm, SATA) (Personal Computers) Does not hold quite what it promises but just great!XEO Shisha2Go - Wild Blueberry, electric shisha (Personal Care) Average battery because does not keep the load or too ...Levipower Laptop Battery [11.1V / 5200mAh / Li-ion] replacement for Dell Studio 1535, Studio 1536, Studio 1537, Studio 1555, Studio 1557, Studio 1558, Studio PP33L, Studio PP39L (Personal Computers) A bit old fashioned and colorless, does not hold what the advertising promisesBerydale Women pullovers in springtime pastel colors (Textiles) does not keep the load 1Battery ORIGINAL NOKIA BL-5K for Nokia C7 (Wireless Phone Accessory) An alarm clock that does not keep its promisesTFA 98.1043 "Nostalgia" electronic alarm clock (household goods) A connected watch that does not keep promisesSony SmartWatch 2 Mobile Watch connected Bluetooth 3.0 / NFC - Smartphone Android - Silicone Wristband Black (Electronics) Beautiful part, but does not keep all its promises.Knipex 1242195 MultiStrip 10 automatic wire stripper (tool) Does not keep what is promised, am disappointedL'Oréal Paris Volume Million Lashes mascara, black (Personal Care) Extensively tested, super game, but does not keep all its promisesPlants vs. Zombies: Garden Warfare - [Xbox One] (Video Game) does not keep its promises 11FVS318G-100EUS Netgear Firewall Router 8-port Gigabit Lan (Personal Computers) Pretty to look at - but does not keep the promise.Logitech Harmony Remote Control 1000 Universal remote control (optional) Efficient and beautiful case protection that does not spoil anything ....Case Logic Case for iPad Mini CSIE2140K / iPad Mini 3 Black (Personal Computers) USB BIOS flashback does not keep its promises.Asus Z97I-PLUS Mini ITX Motherboard Intel Intel Socket 1150 (Accessory) Finally, an alarm clock that does not keep you awakeNAF NAF V2 MORNING - Clock Radio PLL 2 ultra compact alarms. (Electronic devices)