I just decided for this because my last Dressing Shaker is gone (from glass) to break and I wanted a cheaper substitute. Actually, this product is not bad and he does what he should. He Shake't salad dressing or what you want Shaken halt. But unfortunately, the closure is not tight. Therefore only 3 stars from me because I now belongs to the top layer of the dressing shaker. and these products can objectively assess: D Thanks for the read Lg