Function follows form?

Function follows form?

Microsoft Sculpt Ergonomic Desktop Cordless black (Accessories)

Customer Review

I highly recommend this set very, recommend very limited.

Keyboard:
Keyboard size, keystroke, the curved shape seem ideal to me. Increasing the keyboard front with the included bracket, the hands are pleasant on a pretty soft palm rest. Generally the keyboard makes a noble and high-quality impression, not least because the mentioned support slips into its holder uncomplicated by magnetic.
The battery compartments are also provided with a magnetic cover, which simply makes opening pleasant.

The serepate keypad seems to make sense to save space, but I have used it since almost not buying the keyboard.

Since it sounds, unfortunately, already on. As valuable may be the ergonomic shape, so serious hit the negative points to book.
It starts with the fact that the right half of my spacebar is a nasty, high squeak when you press it. A quick Google search to foreshadows that this is certainly not an isolated case. Since the keyboard is otherwise very quiet, bothers me that sound when you tap enormous.
Next, the layout - here playful keyboard all my tolerance.
First, one has to bear in mind that the layout, I'm talking about is not the one of the product picture, as some changes can be found in the German layout. The most serious: the left shift key is shrinking in favor of additional "|" button on the smallest key size of the keyboard, only half as wide as the "Caps Lock" key. Mir is too small. To the umlauts was accommodate pushed around in the area of ​​the enter key, however, seems to me the more problematic. Obviously, other layout was given here not a high priority in planning.

To navigate through program code, I often use the arrow keys, and End keys Pos1 and the scroll keys. These have been completely banned in the layout to the edge, and there aligned completely homogeneous. They do not provide special feel, to feel around, to which key is: Distances and arrangement are completely equal, a highlight as on the F and J key does not exist. Just because these buttons require by their location on the keyboard lifting and moving the right hand, my error rate is significantly higher in these keys. It is not understandable to me why the "visually appealing", uniform arrangement of the keys has been brought forward without separate spaces a sensible arrangement. A distance of half width keys or other tactile characteristic would have been enough to make the "buttons Islands" well be felt and recognizable for motor memory.

Also incomprehensible is my step-like arrangement of the keys on the left half. Taking the right-hand man in convenient angle to the keyboard, so you can reach through the simple buckling movement of the fingers easily the appropriate button in the upper or lower row of keys. If you try this move on the left half, so the finger lands in the key gap because the staircase arrangement is not symmetrical, but also here to the "left upstairs" goes. An additional lateral movement of the left finger is necessary. Why is the button layout is not symmetrical for both hands? After all, these are also symmetrical on the keyboard, and if my bio-knowledge is still correct, the hands have no differences in bone and muscle structure. (Yes: The make "normal" keyboards also But this here is supposed to be ergonomic..)

Finally, the combined Fn and multimedia keys are to call at the top. There is no Fn key, but a slide switch in the upper right corner of the keyboard. This is the smallest (!) operating element around the keyboard, and from a sitting position in front of the keyboard can not reliably detect the position in which this is. I have to actually prevent to make sure that it is in the correct position, if I want to press for example, Alt-F4 or similar combinations - just in my programming environment I have to do often; but I also like to steer with the keyboard my music. An unmitigated disaster. Even if you try, simple Always operate the switch, and then press the function key, you have enormous reusable because it can be pushed through its secluded location not conveniently located near the function keys. Sensing the position of the switch can be hardly to not at all. For special scorn perched next to the toggle switch to "Calculator" button - bigger, easier to achieve, but unfortunately a lot of useless.

The gap between the keyboard halves makes from this point in a bad mood. Apparently, yes there was not enough space to accommodate everything clever, but in the middle of media buttons would certainly have had a very, very good position. At least one FN key in the upper, central area would have been an enrichment - could be so sure-handed use the function keys and media keys (!). Instead, there is this stylish cut.

Conclusion: obviously different interests were involved in this keyboard. The form seems ergonomically, but everything else suffers from the optical design of the keyboard.

For mouse!
The mouse is large and offers - at least in my hand - a good grip shape. The material of the thumb rest is pleasant.

The material of the mouse buttons feels not good. In my eyes (and hands) affects the glossy plastic cheap. In addition, it smeared quickly. The key click is relatively loud and sounds like 10 year old office on mice, feels the touch for good. The scroll wheel is serving and has no special features.
Under the Windows key has a thumb button. This has a much higher pressure point as the two mouse buttons - so high that I need to stabilize the mouse with the little finger, so they do not wobble when I press this button sideways. This attitude does not seem to take tensed ergonomically me. Since I work on three monitors, even the occasional lifting and placing new mouse is inevitable. Here, one finds that it has a relatively large weight. As long as the mouse rarely needs new positioning, but this will hardly be noticeable.

I find it a pity that the good base is made of so many small defects canceled out. I see this set just as in good hands, where the user wants to do little more than write texts, surfing, listening to music - that in turn is good, the tap makes almost fun. As long as the space bar does not squeak.
For me at least, the keyboard will not find a new home - I do not too much money, that some aspects of, for example, programming work are counterproductive.

Turbo Peeler 1 Rank: 5/5
February 27
telescope 2 Rank: 5/5
December 26
Super 1880 1225 Rank: 5/5
July 22
Not bad a start Rank: 3/5
December 24
Case compact xperia z3 Rank: 4/5
December 14

Related Reviews


A fine example of 'form follows function' [1]Cullmann magnesite Copter Multi tripod incl. CB2.7 ball head (Accessories) Unfortunately, Great design comes at the expense of functionalityWMF 0413150011 Lono glass kettle, 1.7 L (household goods) Good remote, but combined function does not work properlyOne For All URC 6440 Universal Remote Control with 4 Simple SimpleSet for PC connection (optional) Affordable program with sufficient functionsThe Bible: on mini-CD-ROM. NASB (CD-ROM) V800: a GPS RF multisport clock like no other! Practical tests in Trainingsmix to Marathon; Tests & comparisons (eg Fenix ​​2)Polar training computers V800, Black, 90,047,437 (equipment) PSE 11 with a new lookAdobe Photoshop Elements 11 (DVD-ROM) a SmartWatch still a lot needs to catch up - my 1st weekendSamsung Galaxy Gear V700 SmartWatch (4.14 cm (1.63 inches) sAMOLED display, 800 MHz, 512MB RAM, Android 4.3) black (accessories) Optimal entry-level modelLenovo Flex 2-15D 39.6 cm (15.6-inch HD LED) Convertible Notebook (AMD A6-6310, 2.4 GHz, 4GB RAM, 500GB HDD Hybrid (8 GB SSD), Radeon R5 M230 2 GB, Touch Screen, no operating system ) Black (Personal Computers) To understand and hard to miss, since rejoice eyes and ears.DBPOWER® BX-200 Portable Wireless Bluetooth Speaker Portable Transparent Speaker with Clock for iPhone, iPad, Samsung Galaxy, Nokia, HTC, Blackberry, Google, LG, Nexus and other Bluetooth devices, support MP3 / WMA / WAV / APE / FLAC, 10 - 20 m Bluetooth range, with German manual, Black (Electronics) Wonderful Wallet for carHama CD Wallet 28, graphite (Accessories) Bosch dryer on Miele washer - watch out!WTZ 11310 Connection kit f. "Sensitive" (Misc.) Without Updates & Wifi it will come with no-name cartridgesEpson Expression Home XP-415 multifunction printer (copier, scanner, printer, WLAN, USB 2.0) (Personal Computers) Excellent equipment, software but only 2 starsBrother P-touch Label Printer QL570 (USB 2.0) Black / Silver (Office supplies & stationery) This fully automatic machine is almost unbeatable!Melitta E 970-103 black Kaffeevollautomat Caffeo CI -One-touch function LCD display -Milchbehälter (household goods) cheaper VCR - rudimentary comfortPhilips VR 752 HiFi VCR (Electronics) The best leather cover I've ever had for a mobile phone!Supremery® handmade Genuine Leather UltraSlim 'Flip' Case, Case for Huawei Ascend Mate 7, Black (Electronics) too tight for large familiesMoulinex Robot Pastry QA403G01 Multifunction Masterchef Gourmet Ruby Red (Kitchen) Murakami's Modern Fairy TaleThe Strange Library (Paperback) OdysseySaga of the Swamp Thing 6 (Hardcover)