Germany 28th place

This year to win by a massive Internet hype the wildcard winner the ticket for Euro Vision Song Contest. That the whole show was a spoof only the audience, let's leave undecided. After all, have lost money on calls for the actual winner Andreas going thousands of people.
In my opinion and the NDR to organize entirely the wrong decision of Ann Sophie no elections. Of course, Ann Sophie was second. But Mr going would not even begun, had more artists can present a second song and probably won.
In general, the format is ridiculous. For weeks, all of Germany can cheer with young artists on the net and TV and then selects course in the finals again the young artists.

Now it may be the Black Smoke represent Germany (must).
Ann Sophie is vocally shaky and in no Weie somehow extraordinary. There is also with Black Smoke a Allerweltsliedchen fades.
It does not take a prophet to predict a European place 20-28 of this "masterpiece" at the end. Of course, by those in charge of song gelob in the sky ....
Thank you dear NDR - the receipt you will reap with viewing figures this year and next!

Conclusion:
Singing: 2 Stars
Melody: 1 Star
Instrumental: 1 Star
Text: 3 stars

Overall impression: 2 Stars