Henri Guillemin, historian Sunday

Henri Guillemin, historian Sunday

Jeanne, called Joan of Arc (Paperback)

Customer Review

Mr. Guillemin is not a historian. He has no idea what historical rigor and study of authentic texts. Without going into details, some ideas on how to Guillemin:

Example: "Many times I saw the bath and ovens, as far as I could see, I think she was a virgin." (Marguerite The Touroulde, resident of Bourges, the rehabilitation trial testimony - 1456, only evidence known of these baths ovens Bourges needless to say).
This in fact Mr. Guillemin "At Bourges, she daily stations in hot water Why not She gladly offer technical masseuses Why not.?.?" (P 133.).

Another example: "Who gave you to call a man to the official nature of Toul involved Wedding Response Jeanne:" I did so not quote, but it was he who made me quote, and there I sworn before the judge to tell truth to this man I had made no promises. "(Trial of condemnation - 1431, only testimony heard this case).
This in fact Henri Guillemin "Then (in 1428) that Jeanne had severe Adventure She gets dragged to justice before the official nature of Toul by a young man who is accused of having broken. a formal promise of marriage. So she loved a boy, she wanted him to take her in his arms, she even had to tell him she did not rule out the idea of ​​marrying ... In saying yes or nearly so the boy he liked, who had moved, disturbed, it was breaking Jeanne consumed, otherwise serious than that which the young man will ask him to account. The stranger who almost do that there had never Joan of Arc Here precisely It occurs in the spring of 1428;?. and without doubt it is not indifferent to see the episode to be at spring when the sap rise .. . This boy who desires, who wants to marry and has, so to speak, not look far as she had his mind elsewhere, why not, my God, why not? She surrenders She looks at him and made him welcome. It's a good party. They go out together, she has had to give him his lips ... "(p. 33-34, 37-38.).

What more if not to ignore Mr. Guillemin if you really want to know the history of Joan of Arc.

MANDATORY 25 October 1326 Rank: 5/5
April 28
92 Mixed Review Rank: 3/5
May 14
DVD R DL 1 Rank: 4/5
December 23
Closure review Rank: 2/5
August 18