With regard to the "Live" CD one has to wonder about the title selection. Okay, Mother and Father, Like a Prayer or Lament are super and certify unsuspected vocal qualities.
But why one has chosen Hollywood and The Beast Within? Madonna was not even on stage at these pieces.
Vogue, Nobody Knows Me and Die Another Day are full playback and American Life is only partly "live".
Why has not the real selected "live" titles like Frozen, Do not Tell Me, Express Yourself, Crazy For You, Material Girl or Nothing Fails? Thus, the CD remains significantly below expectations.