Already the third of this type mascara. With the mascara I am basically very satisfied: The lashes nice tight and full, the handling when removing make straightforward (if you like it says on the box, takes only warm water for removing makeup.) PROBLEM: In all three specimens was long before the ink was all that plastic around it broke, which resulted in regularly that I could (too short for the price !!!) throw away the product after a relatively short time. Now I'm looking for an alternative, a fourth attempt I can save.